Comparison of Two Evacuation Shelter Operating Policies and the Role of Public Health Nurses after the Great East Japan Earthquake: A Qualitative Study

Abstract

This study describes shelter operations by public health nurses (PHNs) in Kesennuma City, located near the epicenter of the Great East Japan Earthquake, which occurred on March 11, 2011. The data were semi-structured interviews with 10 PHNs, 2 nutritionists, and 2 general administrators conducted from July 2013 to January 2014. All transcripts were analyzed using the constructivist grounded theory approach. We identified two operating methods for shelters: shelters stationed by PHNs in the Old City, and shelters patrolled by PHNs in the merged district. These methods were compared using four themes. In emergency situations, “operational periods,” a predetermined short term for a leader to perform his/her duties responsibly, could be adopted for relatively small organizations on the frontline. PHNs must not only attempt to operate shelters on their own but also encourage residents to manage the shelters as well. Moreover, human resource allocation should be managed independently of personal factors, as strong relationships between shelter residents would sometimes disturb the flexibility of the response. Even when a situation requires PHNs to stay in shelters, frequent collecting of information and updating the plan according to response progress will help to maintain effective shelter operations.

Components of hospital personnel preparedness to evacuate patients in disasters: a systematic review

“…These will only be implemented with the training of managers, including hospital managers, matrons and supervisors. Despite the importance of training in clarifying hospital evacuation processes in disaster situations, studies have yet to be conducted worldwide using educational intervention or RCT in this field [ 19 , 26 , 43 ]. Therefore, one of the significant results of this study is showing the insufficient number of training studies for the target groups to evacuate the hospital in accidents.…”

Field Report of the 2024 Noto Peninsula Earthquake—Current Status and Challenges of Evacuation Centers in Wajima City

“…In the wake of the Great East Japan Earthquake, one study compared evacuation centers with professional public health nurses on duty and evacuation centers without them. According to Mori et al, having a public health nurse permanently present is advantageous in building relationships with evacuees [15]. It is believed that having a public health nurse permanently stationed at a facility was advantageous in managing the health of evacuees and making use of their expertise.…”

Key issues in Japan’s public health centers to prepare for future pandemics: a text mining study using a topic model

“…The public health centers provided services such as infectious disease monitoring, HIV/AIDS and intractable disease management, mental health services, elderly health care, maternal and child health care, as well as food hygiene, sanitation, and medical care supervision [8,10]. Additionally, these centers served as key response hubs during health crises, including natural disasters and infectious disease outbreaks [11,12]. When infectious diseases, such as measles, rubella, and tuberculosis, emerged, public health centers swiftly responded [10].…”