“…As a result, it remains unclear how assessments can realistically be made of the ecological resilience of benthic habitats on the NWS, nor of the 'significance' of observed changes in relation to dredging (see also Larcombe & Ridd, 2015). However, given the clear evidence for highly active bed sediment dynamics on the NW shelf (Larcombe et al 2014), the existing understanding of similar tropical and sub-tropical cyclone-influenced carbonate continental shelves in Australia (Belperio, 1983;Gagan et al, 1988Gagan et al, , 1990Larcombe & Carter, 2004) and those elsewhere (Mearns, 1988;Morton, 1988;Hubbard, 1992), there appears a clear case for review of these guidelines and a new approach to seabed assessment. There is strong evidence that EIA-associated work to assess physical impacts of dredging and disruption of sediment transport pathways is lacklustre (Table 5).…”