Comparison of scatter rejection and low‐contrast performance of scan equalization digital radiography (SEDR), slot‐scan digital radiography, and full‐field digital radiography systems for chest phantom imaging

Abstract

Purpose: To investigate and compare the scatter rejection properties and low-contrast performance of the scan equalization digital radiography ͑SEDR͒ technique to the slot-scan and conventional full-field digital radiography techniques for chest imaging. Methods: A prototype SEDR system was designed and constructed with an a-Se flat-panel ͑FP͒ detector to improve image quality in heavily attenuating regions of an anthropomorphic chest phantom. Slot-scanning geometry was used to reject scattered radiation without attenuating primary x rays. The readout scheme of the FP was modified to erase accumulated scatter signals prior to image readout. A 24-segment beam width modulator was developed to regulate x-ray exposures regionally and compensate for the low x-ray flux in heavily attenuating regions. To measure the scatter-to-primary ratios ͑SPRs͒, a 2 mm thick lead plate with a 2-D array of aperture holes was used to measure the primary signals, which were then subtracted from those obtained without the lead plate to determine scatter components. A 2-D array of aluminum beads ͑3 mm in diameter͒ was used as the low-contrast objects to measure the contrast ratios ͑CRs͒ and contrast-to-noise ratios ͑CNRs͒ for evaluating the low-contrast performance in chest phantom images. A set of two images acquired with the same techniques were subtracted from each other to measure the noise levels. SPRs, CRs, and CNRs of the SEDR images were measured in four anatomical regions of chest phantom images and compared to those of slot-scan images and full-field images acquired with and without antiscatter grid. Results: The percentage reduction of SPR ͑percentage of SPRs reduced with scatter removal/ rejection methods relative to that for nongrid full-field imaging͒ averaged over four anatomical regions was measured to be 80%, 83%, and 71% for SEDR, slot-scan, and full-field with grid, respectively. The average CR over four regions was found to improve over that for nongrid fullfield imaging by 259%, 279%, and 145% for SEDR, slot-scan, and full-field with grid, respectively. The average CNR over four regions was found to improve over that for nongrid full-field imaging by 201% for SEDR as compared to 133% for the slot-scan technique and 14% for the antiscatter grid method. Conclusions: Both SEDR and slot-scan techniques outperformed the antiscatter grid method used in standard full-field radiography. For imaging with the same effective exposure, the SEDR technique offers no advantage over the slot-scan method in terms of SPRs and CRs. However, it improves CNRs significantly, especially in heavily attenuating regions. The improvement of lowcontrast performance may help improve the detection of the lung nodules or other abnormalities and may offer SEDR the potential for dose reduction in chest radiography.

Experimental realization of fluence field modulated CT using digital beam attenuation

“…Tube current modulation (Kalender et al 1999) and the use of bowtie filters (Graham et al 2007, Toth et al 2007 are two common methods used to reduce patient dose, detector dynamic range requirements and x-ray scatter. The positive results of modulating the incident exposure as a function of the imaging object are well-known in two-dimensional projection imaging as well and work was carried out in the 1980's that led to the development of a clinical product capable of dose modulation for different parts of a single radiograph (Plewes 1983, Plewes and Vogelstein 1983, Veldkamp et al 2005, Molloi et al 2001, Liu et al 2011.…”

Impact of AI-based Real Time Image Quality Feedback for Chest Radiographs in the Clinical Routine

“…This improvement associated with a significant reduction of the average unnecessarily exposed area during image acquisition. Thus, the achieved improvements help to reduce patient dose, but they will also contribute to reduce scattered radiation (26)(27)(28)(29). The optimal collimation in left-right direction also suggests proper centering of the patient in front of the automatic exposure chambers.…”

Investigation of the origin of scatter components transmitted through anti-scatter grids in X-ray Digital Imaging system using Monte Carlo Simulation

“…Of the several applications, chest X-ray (CXR) is the most indicated for diagnosing pulmonary diseases and viral pneumonia associated with Covid-19 1 . According to studies reported 2 , 44% of all X-ray diagnostic imaging procedures performed in 2006 worldwide were CXR and examination requests are on the increase. Digitization has led to replacement of film-based conventional CXR to digital radiography (DR) and CXR-Computed Tomography (CXR-CT) using flat panel detectors (FPDs).…”