Comparison of Opioid Prescribing Patterns in the United States and Japan: Primary Care Physicians' Attitudes and Perceptions

Abstract

Introduction: Far fewer opioids are prescribed in Japan than in the United States.Methods: We conducted an online physician survey assessing attitudes and perceptions that might influence prescribing. A Japanese version was distributed to members of the Japan Primary Care Association and an English version to members of the American Academy of Family Physicians practicing in Oregon.Results: We received 461 Japanese responses and 198 from the United States, though overall response rates were low (Japan: 10.1%, United States: 18.5%). Japanese respondents reported far less opioid prescribing than US respondents, especially for acute pain (acute pain: 49.4% vs 97.0%; chronic pain: 63.7% vs 90.9%; P < .001 for both). Almost half of respondents from both countries indicated that patient expectations and satisfaction were important factors that influence prescribing. US respondents were significantly more likely to identify medical indication and legal expectation as reasons to prescribe opioids for acute pain. Most US respondents (95.4%) thought opioids were used too often, versus 6.6% of Japanese respondents.

Chronic Opioid Prescribing in Primary Care: Factors and Perspectives

“…15 Despite these guidelines, there remains substantial variation in the practice of prescribing opioids. [19][20][21] Although other studies have examined large-scale variations, [22][23][24][25] little is known about the patient-and clinician-specific factors associated with any opioid and chronic opioid prescribing in primary care. The reliance in these studies on claims data limited the examination of patient, clinician, and practice characteristics.…”

International comparison of mitigation strategies for addressing opioid misuse: A systematic review

“…Japan was the first Asian country to develop legislation to control opioid use; opioid abuse was reportedly nonexistent in Japan until the last few decades. 35 With more than 126 million people, Japan is the globe's 11th most populous country. 13 As of 2015, 87% of the population was 15 years or older, 36 and the prevalence of drug use disorders in people aged 15 years or older is 0.01%, which is the lowest reported value among the compared countries.…”

The Contemporary American Drug Overdose Epidemic in International Perspective

“…In Japan, opioids are rarely prescribed for several reasons: physicians must undergo lengthy training to prescribe opioids for non‐cancer pain, most pharmacies do not stock opioids due to strict storage requirements, and oxycodone is not covered by insurance for non‐cancer pain (Onishi et al. ). In most European countries, morphine, not oxycodone, remains the strong opioid of choice for pain treatment (Karanges et al.…”

“…Prior to 2008, Norway did not reimburse opioids for non-cancer pain (Hamunen et al 2008). In Japan, opioids are rarely prescribed for several reasons: physicians must undergo lengthy training to prescribe opioids for non-cancer pain, most pharmacies do not stock opioids due to strict storage requirements, and oxycodone is not covered by insurance for non-cancer pain (Onishi et al 2017). In most European countries, morphine, not oxycodone, remains the strong opioid of choice for pain treatment (Karanges et al 2016;Weisberg et al 2014;Zin, Chen, and Knaggs 2014), and methadone is used primarily for addiction treatment, not pain management (Weisberg and Stannard 2013;Weisberg et al 2014).…”