Comparison of musculoskeletal disorder health claims between construction floor layers and a general working population

Abstract

Objectives Compare rates of medical insurance claims for musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) between workers in a construction trade and a general worker population to determine if higher physical exposures in construction lead to higher rates of claims on personal medical insurance. Methods Health insurance claims between 2006 and 2010 from floor layers were frequency matched by age, gender, eligibility time, and geographic location to claims from insured workers in general industry obtained from MarketScan. We extracted MSD claims and dates of service from six regions of the body: neck, low back, knee, lower extremity, shoulder, and distal arm, and evaluated differences in claim rates. Results Fifty-one percent of floor layers (n=1,475) experienced musculoskeletal claims compared to 39% of MarketScan members (p<0.001). Claim rates were higher for floor layers across all body regions with nearly double the rate ratios for the knee and neck regions (RR: 2.10 and 2.07). The excess risk was greatest for the neck and low back regions; younger workers had disproportionately higher rates in the knee, neck, low back, and distal arm. A larger proportion of floor layers (22%) filed MSD claims in more than one body region compared to general workers (10%; p<0.001). Conclusions Floor layers have markedly higher rates of MSD claims compared to a general worker population, suggesting shifting of medical costs for work-related MSD to personal health insurance. The occurrence of disorders in multiple body regions and among the youngest workers highlights the need for improved work methods and tools for construction workers.

Comparative analyses of workers' compensation claims of injury among temporary and permanent employed workers in Ohio

“…Overexertion and bodily reaction injuries are also typically associated with repeated, cumulative exposures over time and longer tenure, while temporary workers may not stay on the job long enough to develop musculoskeletal symptoms. There may also be an increased under‐reporting of such musculoskeletal injuries among temporary workers, as has been noted in other industries such as construction . Since 46.4% of temporary agency workers report preferring a traditional work arrangement, there could be added incentive among temporary workers to not report injuries in hopes that this could increase chances of being offered full‐time employment.…”

Personal and occupational risk factors for carpal tunnel syndrome in meat processing industry workers in Northern Italy

“…In the US only, medical costs for the CTS have been estimated to amount to 2 billion dollars annually, primarily due to surgical releases [4], and the median sick leave from the CTS is 25-27 days, which is longer than any other workrelated disorder except fractures [5,6].…”

Influence of work organization and work environment on missed work, productivity, and use of pain medications among construction apprentices

“…They differ from older workers in having less autonomy and job security, and also by having fewer years of cumulative exposure to heavy physical work and to workplace psychosocial stressors. While younger construction workers have markedly higher rates of chronic musculoskeletal disorders than a general working population, older construction workers have even higher rates of chronic musculoskeletal disorders, which are associated with work limitation, missed work, and reduced physical functioning . We studied carpenters and floorlayers, though other literature suggests that the work environment, work exposures, and outcomes we assessed are common across other construction trades.…”