Comparison of imaging parameters between OCT, GDx and HRT in the Northern Finland birth cohort eye study

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose of the study was to assess and compare the optic nerve head (ONH) and retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) parameters and image quality parameters obtained by Cirrus HD-OCT, GDxECC and HRT3 in a populationbased screening study. Methods: This analysis examined 2566 subjects taking part in the Northern Finland Birth Cohort Eye study. Images with spectral domain OCT (Cirrus HD-OCT 4000), scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (HRT3) and scanning laser polarimetry (GDxECC) were obtained from each subject. The correlation of average and regional parameters of RNFL and ONH between devices was evaluated. Results: The RNFL thickness was 90.9 µm when measured with OCT, 24.6 µm with HRT and 48.1 µm with GDx. There was a high correlation between the disc and cup measurements with the HRT and OCT and the RNFL thickness of the OCT and GDx (r > 0.5). A statistically significant correlation was found between RNFL measurements of the HRT and OCT in the superior, temporal and inferior quadrants. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) signal strength correlated with the image quality parameters of the HRT and GDx. The percentage of good quality images was the lowest with the GDx. Conclusion:The RNFL thickness in Northern Finland birth cohort was at a lower level compared to other studies. The study confirms the difference in measuring ONH parameters between the imaging devices. However, significant correlations between devices were found in the cup volume and cup disc area ratio parameters of the OCT and HRT. The correlations between image quality parameters and glaucoma detection parameters were relatively low.

Interocular symmetry and intermachine reproducibility measured by two different models of Cirrus optical coherence tomography

“…Furthermore, the application of OCT in measuring RNFL thickness at a few micrometers enables us to precisely and promptly evaluate therapeutic effects on intracranial hypertension(8, 9). Cirrus spectral domain high de nition (HD)-OCT 4000 has since 2007 been used as a diagnostic device in macula and RNFL (10,11). The model was upgraded into Cirrus 5000 in 2012 to take advantage of fast scan speed to enhance work ow e ciency and a fast tracker to compensate for blinking and eye movements (12,13).…”