Comparison of Dry and Gel Based Electrodes for P300 Brain–Computer Interfaces

Abstract

Most brain–computer interfaces (BCIs) rely on one of three types of signals in the electroencephalogram (EEG): P300s, steady-state visually evoked potentials, and event-related desynchronization. EEG is typically recorded non-invasively with electrodes mounted on the human scalp using conductive electrode gel for optimal impedance and data quality. The use of electrode gel entails serious problems that are especially pronounced in real-world settings when experts are not available. Some recent work has introduced dry electrode systems that do not require gel, but often introduce new problems such as comfort and signal quality. The principal goal of this study was to assess a new dry electrode BCI system in a very common task: spelling with a P300 BCI. A total of 23 subjects used a P300 BCI to spell the word “LUCAS” while receiving real-time, closed-loop feedback. The dry system yielded classification accuracies that were similar to those obtained with gel systems. All subjects completed a questionnaire after data recording, and all subjects stated that the dry system was not uncomfortable. This is the first field validation of a dry electrode P300 BCI system, and paves the way for new research and development with EEG recording systems that are much more practical and convenient in field settings than conventional systems.

BCI Could Make Old Two-Player Games Even More Fun: A Proof of Concept with “Connect Four”

“…In most applications, a reliable command can only be achieved by accumulating data over long time windows, at the expense of the primary interest of the game. Another drawback is the obvious one of having to put an EEG cap on, although the field has made tremendous progress in that respect in the last few years [18]. For all those reasons today, BCI hardly compete with traditional game effectors such as joysticks, mice, and keyboards, at least in healthy subjects.…”

The Evaluation of Different EEG Sensor Technologies

“…g.SAHARA, g.tec, AT) or a water based system (e.g. Mobita, TMSi, Twente Medical Systems International BV, Netherlands) [6][7][8]. (3) Connection to amplifier: Electrodes may also be distinguished by the method how they are connected to the amplifier.…”

Affective brain-computer interfaces: Special Issue editorial

“…However, many other directions may be relatively close to market, catalyzed by more portable, practical, comfortable, and powerful tools to record the EEG. [9,10] Companies have been selling systems called 'BCIs' for home use for a several years, which often incorporate affective information into games and help buyers monitor concentration or relaxation. Noninvasive systems that do not require medical certification and rely on inexpensive, practical electrodes could get aBCI technologies to users fairly quickly.…”