Comparison of carprofen and tramadol for postoperative analgesia in dogs undergoing enucleation

Abstract

Objective To compare analgesia provided by carprofen or tramadol in dogs after enucleation. Design Randomized, masked trial Animals Forty-three dogs Procedures Client-owned dogs admitted for routine enucleation were randomly assigned to receive either carprofen or tramadol orally 2 hours prior to surgery and 12 hours after the first dose. Dogs were scored for pain at baseline, and postoperatively at 0.25, 0.5, 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 24, and 30 hours after extubation. Dogs received identical premedication and inhalation anesthesia regimens, including premedication with hydromorphone. If the total pain score was ≥9, if there was a score ≥ 3 in any one category, or if the visual analog scale score (VAS) was ≥35 combined with a palpation score of >0, rescue analgesia (hydromorphone) was administered and treatment failure was recorded. Characteristics between groups were compared with a Student’s t-test and Fisher’s exact test. The incidence of rescue was compared between groups using a log rank test. Pain scores and VAS scores between groups were compared using repeated measures ANOVA. Results There was no difference in age (p=0.493), gender (p=0.366) or baseline pain scores (p=0.288) between groups. Significantly more dogs receiving tramadol required rescue analgesia (6/21) compared to dogs receiving carprofen (1/22; p=0.035). Pain and VAS scores decreased linearly over time (p=0.038, p<0.001, respectively). There were no significant differences in pain (p=0.915) or VAS scores (p=0.372) between groups at any time point (dogs were excluded from analysis after rescue). Conclusions and Clinical Relevance This study suggests that carprofen, with opioid premedication, provides more effective post-operative analgesia than tramadol in dogs undergoing enucleation.

Investigation and management of canine osteoarthritis

“…Tramadol is metabolised into eight substrates of which only one is active in the dog, and that is only for a short (one to two hours) period. If tramadol is used, careful monitoring of the patient is needed to ensure adequate levels of analgesia are provided (Delgado andothers 2014, Benitez andothers 2015).…”

The present and future of opioid analgesics in small animal practice

“…In addition, the nonopioid mechanisms of action of tramadol produced limited antinociception in an acute pain model in dogs (Kögel et al ., ). NSAIDs and pure μ ‐opioid receptor agonists provided more effective analgesia when compared with tramadol in dogs undergoing orthopedic and ophthalmic procedures (Cardozo et al ., ; Delgado et al ., ).…”

The Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ 2016 Veterinary Medical Care Guidelines for Spay-Neuter Programs

“…Some analgesic agents, such as orally administered tramadol, are associated with greater variability in response than others. [251][252][253][254] Because multimodal treatment will improve analgesia for most patients, its use is recommended whenever possible.…”