Comparison of biomechanical performance of titanium and polyaryletheretherketone miniscrews at different insertion angles: A finite element analysis

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Only miniscrews [temporary anchoring devices, (TADs)] can provide absolute anchorage during orthodontic treatment. Titanium (Ti) is a fundamental material used in the production of miniscrews, but it has many disadvantages. Polyaryletheretherketone (PEEK) may have various benefits in the production of miniscrews. Finite element analysis (FEA) is a valid and reliable method for calculating stress, strain, and loading forces on complex structures and can be more time- and cost-efficient. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the biomechanical performance of Ti and PEEK as miniscrew biomaterials employing FEA. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This study is a 3-D (3D) simulation with FEA. First, 3D miniscrew modeling is done using Ti base material and PEEK (1.4 mm × 6 mm size), as well as 3D inter-radicular space bone modeling. The simulation was performed by modeling the insertion angles (30°, 60°, and 90°) and applying a 200-gram loading force. The biomechanical performance of the miniscrew was then determined using FEA. RESULTS: As the angle of insertion increases, the tension on the bone decreases, the stress on the TADs increases, and the bone deformation decreases. Compared to TADs made of Ti and PEEK, TADs made of PEEK alone cause more bone stress than TADs made of Ti. The distortion in the maxilla is observed to be larger than in the mandibular. CONCLUSION: PEEK has greater stress on the bones than Ti and may be prospected as an alternative biomaterial for TAD fabrication, as documented in the FEA.

Effect of cortical bone thickness on shear stress and force in orthodontic miniscrew-bone interface – A finite element analysis

“…At 30°angulation with 2.66 CBT , the shear stress in the interface region of T2 screw was 22% higher than 0°angulation as shown in figure 5. In line with our results a study showed when the angulation increased, the stress in miniscrew also increased due to the reduction of tension in bone [32].…”