Comparison of a Spectral Microphysics and a Two-Moment Cloud Scheme: Numerical Simulations of the Cloud-Topped Marine Boundary Layer

Abstract

A comparison between the spectral microphysics cloud scheme (MiStra) and the parametrized cloud scheme (PaStra) is presented. The main feature of MiStra consists of the treatment of aerosol particles, cloud droplets, and drizzle particles in a joint two-dimensional particle size distribution, whereas PaStra consists of a two-moment scheme for cloud droplets combined with a one-moment scheme for drizzle. Both cloud schemes have been implemented in a single-column model of the cloud-topped marine boundary layer. Numerical sensitivity studies are presented demonstrating that MiStra is capable of simulating in great detail the major cloud microphysical processes occurring in low-level stratiform clouds. While in MiStra no empirical parameter is available to tune the model, the empirical model parameters of PaStra have been tuned by means of the MiStra model results. By comparing the numerical results of PaStra with those of MiStra it is found that PaStra simulates the overall characteristics of the cloud-topped marine boundary layer quite well. At the same time, however, the effects of single cloud microphysical processes differ substantially from those of MiStra. Finally, it is shown that even in PaStra the inclusion of all major cloud microphysical processes is mandatory in order to obtain appropriate results.

A description of the first open-source community release of MISTRA-v9.0: a 0D/1D atmospheric boundary layer chemistry model

“…The collision-coalescence process was implemented in a version of MISTRA without chemistry (Bott, 2000), hereafter referred to as MISTRA-coal-nochem for brevity. In a recent study, Bott (2020) used MISTRA-coal-nochem and compared the results with and without activating this process (Fig. 6).…”

“…6b). We defined a namelist, named Bott2020, reproducing the same settings as in Bott (2020), to perform a further evaluation of MISTRA-v9.0 against MISTRA-coal-nochem. The resulting 1D particle distribution is presented in Fig.…”

A description of the first open source community release of the 1D atmospheric chemistry model MISTRA-v9.0

“…6b). We defined a namelist, named Bott2020, reproducing the same settings as in Bott (2020) to perform a further evaluation of MISTRA-v9.0 against MISTRA-coal-nochem. The resulting one-dimensional particle distribution is presented in Fig.…”