Our institute established an eye plaque interstitial brachytherapy (EPIBT) program in 2007 using the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) eye plaque. In this case report, we demonstrated an eye plaque treatment planned and executed using Eye Physics Plaque (Los Alamitos, CA) for a 72-year-old male patient with an extra-large tumor with a maximum width of 18.6 mm and height of 13.7 mm. The use of a customized eye plaque, manufactured through three-dimensional (3D) printing, has empowered us to plan and administer treatment for this patient with uveal melanoma. Without this option, enucleation, an option declined by the patient, or proton beam therapy (PBT), which the patient was unwilling to pursue in another state, would have been the alternative course of action. We were able to use more than one activity of the I-125 seeds, which enabled us to shape and reduce the dose to normal surrounding structures at risk within the orbit and in the vicinity of the orbital cavity. Using the dose evaluation tools available with the modern treatment planning system, we reduced the prescription dose from 85 to 70 Gy, with D90 of 140 Gy, thereby providing effective treatment and limiting risk organ doses. In summary, we were able to dose-deescalate without compromising the chances of controlling retinal/scleral tumors. The patient is doing well from a recent follow-up visit 12 months after the eye plaque brachytherapy treatment. The tumor was 4.80 mm high, 1/3 of the original height, and vision is back to 20/60, demonstrating a successful treatment.