Comparing infant and toddler sleep patterns prior to and during the first wave of home confinement due to COVID-19 in Spain

Abstract

Recent literature has shown that sleep patterns are shaped during the first years of life, playing a relevant role in children's functioning. We focused on comparing sleep patterns in infants and toddlers in Spain before and during COVID-19 home confinement to assess the immediate impact on sleep patterns. We compared data from two cross-sectional surveys from parents of 1658 children three to 36 months of age from Spain. One conducted before COVID-19 (2017COVID-19 ( -2018COVID-19 ( , n = 1380 and another during COVID-19 pandemic (March-May of 2020, n = 254). We used an internet self-administrated questionnaire using the Brief Infant Sleep Questionnaire (BISQ) criteria in both surveys. During confinement, infants and toddlers went to sleep later (median bedtime 21:30 before confinement vs. 21:36 during confinement (p = 0.004)). More infants and toddlers showed longer sleep latencies (> 30 min) during confinement median 33.9% versus 12.3% (p < 0.001). Based on the recommended BISQ criteria, we observed an increase in poor sleepers meeting at least one criterion of inadequate patterns during confinement (p < 0.001). Parental perception of a child's sleep as problematics were 39.4% and 44.1% (adjusted p = 0.363) before and under lockdown, respectively.Conclusion: Home confinement generally affected infant's and toddler's sleep patterns negatively; however, parents did not report worse perception of sleep quality of their children. Follow-up studies can help understand the potential long-term effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on sleep patterns. What is Known: • Adequate sleep patterns in infants and toddlers are relevant as they are linked to proper and long-term social-emotional development as well as adequate daytime functioning. • Regarding sleep patterns in paediatrics during the COVID pandemic, recent literature has described an increase in total daily sleep time as well as more exposure to screens in children and adolescents, providing evidence of immediate collateral consequences of the COVID-19 outbreak. What is New: • Comparing sleep patterns in two samples of infants and toddlers in Spain before and during COVID-confinement, we found later bedtimes as well as a significant increase in infants' and toddlers' sleep latency by >30 min during confinement. • Parental self-reported questionnaire during COVID-19 home confinement reported an overall worsening of their children's sleep based on the BISQ criteria. Keywords COVID-19 outbreak • Early childhood • Home confinement • Sleep disturbances • Sleep patterns Abbreviations BISQ Brief Infants Sleep Questionnaire COVID-19 Coronavirus-SARS 2019 pandemic IQR Interquartile range WHO World Health Organisation Communicated by Peter de Winter

The contribution of nutrition and quality of sleep and happiness in under-five-year-old children

“…This shows that there is a relationship between sleep quality and daily mood or emotion, that is, being happy, which is in line with the statement that there is a bi-directional link between sleep and emotions. [ 9 ]…”

Persistence of Lockdown Consequences on Children: A Cross-sectional Comparative Study

“…Furthermore, our two samples are comparable both for socio-cultural and demographic characteristics. It should also be highlighted that although a year later many children were still in isolation and attended remote classes, many parents had returned to their work, thus causing a possible worsening of children’s social skills, especially in early childhood [ 23 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 ]. The main weakness of this study is that our data, although overlapping, do not correspond to the same sample, and still suffer from some bias.…”

How the COVID-19 pandemic has affected children and adolescents’ sleep habits: a systematic review

“…The designs of the studies that utilized validated tools to assess sleep time were variable. Twelve studies have provided comparisons between data collected before and after the pandemic, comparing results from two or more cross-sectional studies [17,18,24,36,41,62,76,79,82,101,119,147]. Six studies have collected data on sleep behaviors retrospectively, by children or their caregivers about changes in sleep quality before and after the COVID-19 outbreak and home confinement [20,22,32,35,42,43,49,91,123].…”