Comparing Combinations of Linear and Nonlinear Feedback Terms for Ship Motion Control

Abstract

In this paper, combinations of linear and nonlinear feedback terms are investigated for 3 degrees-of-freedom pose and velocity control of ships. Nonlinear control algorithms that are found in the literature often have linear feedback terms, which result in nice globally exponential stability properties when assuming no actuator constraints. However, considering that all actuators have saturation constraints, such stability properties are not feasible in practice. Applying nonlinear feedback terms can be a step to handle such constraints. As a result, this paper explores nonlinear feedback terms for both the kinematic and kinetic control loops. Specifically, three controllers based on a cascaded backstepping control design are implemented and compared through simulations and model-scale experiments in an ocean basin. Stability properties and tuning rules for all the controllers are also provided. Interestingly, the use of nonlinear feedback terms gives the ability to constrain the feedback control inputs globally while simultaneously being able to change the convergence rates locally. The price to be paid is the introduction of additional tuning parameters. The three controller types are compared using performance metrics which consider both control accuracy and energy use. INDEX TERMS Ship motion control, Dynamic positioning, Cascaded backstepping control design, Nonlinear feedback terms, Tuning rules, Performance metrics, Experimental results.

ROV-Based Autonomous Maneuvering for Ship Hull Inspection with Coverage Monitoring

“…The desired velocity v d is finally defined to make sure the vehicle reaches the waypoints. It is based on the constant bearing nonlinear approach from [39,40]. It prevents the vehicle from deviating from the path segment by making it converge towards it, while maintaining its velocity along the path.…”

A Guidance and Maneuvering Control System Design with Anti-collision Using Stream Functions with Vortex Flows for Autonomous Marine Vessels

“…We assume that the full state feedback is available for the control design model in (38). A backstepping design will result in our proposed control law, giving a cascade structure in the error states [40,41]. Towards this end, the state is transformed by the error signals as…”

Improvement of Ship Motion Control Using a Magnitude-Rate Saturation Model

“…3) Stability: Based on the theorems and stability proofs in [10], we can conclude that the two controllers have the following stability properties: The origin (z 1 , z 2 ) = (0, 0) is uniformly globally asymptotically stable (UGAS) and on each compact set B ⊂ R 6 containing the origin, it is uniformly exponentially stable (UES) [10]. The MRS model is a nonlinear filter, and it is proven in [4] that the output will be an L 2 signal if the input is an L 2 signal, so it can be concluded that the MRS model does not alter the stability properties of the system.…”

“…4) Parameter tuning: The experiments are conducted with the gain parameters shown in Table II. The choice of the gain parameters for the two controllers are based on the tuning rules described in [10]. Here, the goal is to make the kinetic subsystem faster than the kinematic subsystem, which means that the kinetic subsystem needs to have smaller time constants than the kinematic subsystem in the linear region.…”