Comparative Study on the Characteristics of Community-Based Tourism between Pentingsari and Nglanggeran Tourism Village, Special Region Yogyakarta

Abstract

Community-based tourism is one of the tourism development models that effectively used as a tool to alleviate poverty through empowerment strategy of the local community. Nevertheless, many people do not have adequate understanding on the characteristics of community-based tourism, which are used as a determinant in the tourism development. This article describes the comparison on characteristics of community-based tourism between Pentingsari and Nglanggeran. These villages were chosen because Pentingsari was a tourism village that able to apply the principles ethical codes of world tourism, shown by an award from the World Committee on Tourism Ethics Code and Nglanggeran was awarded as Best Tourism Village award in Indonesia from ASEAN Community Based Tourism Award 2017.The objectives of this study is to explore the characteristics of community-based tourism applied in the Pentingsari and Nglanggeran, and to identify any indicators that could be used to indicate those characteristics. The research achieves through in-depth interviews, observation, and review of documents. There were 17 persons as informants. Further, the observation was reached by directly observing in the both study cases. In addition, the data obtained through the review of secondary data from the local manager of tourism village. Generally, Pentingsari has characteristics as a community-based rural tourism, while Nglanggeran has characteristics as community-based ecotourism.

A Combination of FDM, DEMATEL, and DANP for Disclosing the Interrelationship of Influencing Factors in Rural Homestay Business: Empirical Evidence from China

“…Bhalla and Bhattacharya (2019) stated that visitors' satisfaction as well as perception are the main elements that successfully drive the selection of destination, the consumption of the local products, and the generation of return visits in homestay tourism [26]. Purbasari and Manaf (2018) summarized the characteristic indicators of community-based tourism in Indonesia by comparative analysis, and the success dimensions for CBT from the evaluation research work include local community, good leadership, strong collaboration with government and private agencies, uniqueness of homestay attractions, and environmental conservation [27]. Kayat and Zainuddin (2016) listed 12 criteria of performance success of community-based rural homestays in rural Malaysia by a qualitative method [20].…”

Predicting determinant factors and development strategy for tourist villages

“…The government plays a role as a driver in the process of developing partnerships among stakeholders, developing and overseeing the strategic direction of tourist villages (Koopmans et al, (2018); Liu et al, (2020). To succeed, tourism villages require public partnerships both in the local and global contexts (Purbasari & Manaf, 2018). Research conducted by Kristianto et al (2019) found the critical success factors for developing a tourist village include attractions, facilities, accessibility, image, human resources, and tourism prices.…”

Predicting and determining antecedent factors of tourist village development using naive bayes and tree algorithm

“…In its development, CBT requires public partnerships both in local and global contexts (Purbasari & Manaf, 2018). Regardless of the type of CBT services, these ventures should remain wholly owned, managed, and controlled by community members (or groups of independent micro and small experiences under the same CBT management organization).…”