Comparative evaluation of despeckle filtering in ultrasound imaging of the carotid artery

Abstract

It is well-known that speckle is a multiplicative noise that degrades the visual evaluation in ultrasound imaging. The recent advancements in ultrasound instrumentation and portable ultrasound devices necessitate the need of more robust despeckling techniques for enhanced ultrasound medical imaging for both routine clinical practice and teleconsultation. The objective of this work was to carry out a comparative evaluation of despeckle filtering based on texture analysis, image quality evaluation metrics, and visual evaluation by medical experts in the assessment of 440 (220 asymptomatic and 220 symptomatic) ultrasound images of the carotid artery bifurcation. In this paper a total of 10 despeckle filters were evaluated based on local statistics, median filtering, pixel homogeneity, geometric filtering, homomorphic filtering, anisotropic diffusion, nonlinear coherence diffusion, and wavelet filtering. The results of this study suggest that the first order statistics filter lsmv, gave the best performance, followed by the geometric filter gf4d, and the homogeneous mask area filter lsminsc. These filters improved the class separation between the asymptomatic and the symptomatic classes based on the statistics of the extracted texture features, gave only a marginal improvement in the classification success rate, and improved the visual assessment carried out by the two experts. More specifically, filters lsmv or gf4d can be used for despeckling asymptomatic images in which the expert is interested mainly in the plaque composition and texture analysis; and filters lsmv, gf4d, or lsminsc can be used for the despeckling of symptomatic images in which the expert is interested in identifying the degree of stenosis and the plaque borders. The proper selection of a despeckle filter is very important in the enhancement of ultrasonic imaging of the carotid artery. Further work is needed to evaluate at a larger scale and in clinical practice the performance of the proposed despeckle filters in the automated segmentation, texture analysis, and classification of carotid ultrasound imaging.

An integrated system for the complete segmentation of the common carotid artery bifurcation in ultrasound images

“…The segmentations were based on the Williams & Shah [37] snake segmentation method, which was used to deform the snake and segment the IMC, the atherosclerotic carotid plaque and the near carotid wall borders in each image. The snake v(s), adapts itself by a dynamic process that minimizes an energy function ( ( , ) snake E v s ) defined as [37] : [7,13,[15][16][17][18] .…”

“…Recently, a sional (2D) ultr f a segmentati J IMT. With thi y detecting the h walls (far an re and diagnos ker of atherosc carotid lumen p of the IMT, th mperative and a easurements ar or semi-autom ntation and incr complex (IMC) the artery lume e far and near with 82% lum roposed in the l or the mediastudies reported ore specifically le in a more rec MC snake's ba ended for segm [17][18][19][20] and speck manually segm atherosclerotic MT snakes seg multi resolutio ks [25] with activ were utilized fferent 3D plaq sing the QLAB r the segmentat system for the rasound image ion system as p Journal of Biome is understandin leading echo b nd near wall) o se the extend o clerosis [4,5] . It diameter (D) ( he atherosclero are routinely as re performed m mated (SA) seg rease the accur ) (bands Z5 and en diameter, D walls on the men stenosis.…”

“…It diameter (D) ( he atherosclero are routinely as re performed m mated (SA) seg rease the accur ) (bands Z5 and en diameter, D walls on the men stenosis. Fi literature either -and intima-l d in the literatu y, a review [6] o cent study [16] Figure 1, otic carotid plaq ssessed with hig manually by e gmentation sys racy of the segm d Z6), the athe (band Z4), and image, which igure is reprodu r for the segme ayers [15] , from ture, where a c of different au a review on im ion system was ima-and the m filtering [17] . [1,3 ted through the leading echo b que, the D, as w gh resolution u experts and su stems are there mentation [6][7][8][9][10][11][12] rotid plaque, at ear walls of the d from a 69 ye f. [15] © IEEE T IMC [6][7][8][9] , the D images of the mentation of the A techniques f segmentation s hereas in Ref.…”

CAUDLES-EF: Carotid Automated Ultrasound Double Line Extraction System Using Edge Flow

“…& Step 2: Speckle reduction. Speckle noise is attenuated using a first-order local statistics filter (called lsmv by the authors [12,13]), which has given the best performance in the specific case of carotid imaging. This filter is defined by the following equation:…”

“…The noise-free central pixel in the moving window is indicated by J x,y . Louizou et al [12,13] mathematically defined k x;y ¼ s 2…”