Comparative Analysis of Mortality From Coronavirus Disease 2019 Across the European Union Countries and the Effects of Vaccine Coverage

Abstract

Background Mortality is a critical measure of disease impact. The European Union (EU) countries share the same regulatory framework but different implementation policies. Methods We extracted cumulative COVID-19 mortality data across the EU countries. We evaluated the 27 member states using the location quotient (LQ) to adjust for the expected mortality in the whole EU region, where an LQ <1 signifies a more and an LQ >1 a less favorable outcome. We categorized EU members into 3 distinct profiles based on their LQ estimates: favorable profile, LQ ≤0.9; unfavorable profile, LQ >1.10; and average profile, LQ between 0.9 and 1.10. We compared LQ estimates and profiles with the prevaccination era that ended in December 2020 with the COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Results Twelve member states had a favorable profile, 4 had an average profile, and 11 had an unfavorable profile. In quantitative analysis, an improvement (negative LQ difference) was noted across countries with higher vaccination coverage (median, 71% fully vaccinated vs 57% for countries with positive LQ differences). There was a significant negative association between the share of fully vaccinated and LQ changes (ρ = –0.62, P < .001) and a significant 4-month lag effect. After COVID-19 vaccines became available, 4 countries improved their profile and 5 moved to a worse profile. Conclusions There is significant variability in mortality and impact of COVID-19 between countries, even if they share the same regulatory framework. Extending immunization coverage may lead the transition to a more favorable profile, and alter the trajectory of COVID-19 mortality.

Spatial structure and proximity mechanism of cross-city patient mobility networks in the Yangtze River Economic Belt of China: Based on patient online evaluation data

“…Its core principle is that a service is considered to be of national significance if its regional output value represents a larger share of the region's total output value in comparison to the national average for that service. In health geography research, LQ is primarily used to quantify the concentration levels of various healthcare system elements, such as mortality rates (Ziakas et al, 2022), number of hospital beds (Ford & Smith, 2008), and incidence rates (Moineddin et al, 2003). Based on the LQ, we developed a formula to calculate the Healthcare Relative Size Index (HRS), tailoring it to the specific context of our study.…”

Assessing the impact of the four COVID-19 variants and the vaccine coverage on mortality in Malta over 2 years: An observational case study

“…Mortality is an important index for quantifying the burden of a disease among the population and also constitutes a fundamental pillar for public health decision making (13,14). In this study, we set to assess the impact of COVID-19 in terms of population mortality, while exploring the effect of the four dominant variant phases and the vaccination coverage on the Maltese population.…”

The Paris Conference on Education 2022: Official Conference Proceedings

“…Bulgaria is one of the most impacted by COVID-19 countries in the world in terms of life expectancy decline (Kuehn, 2022), the high mortality rate (Ziakas et al, 2022), low vaccination coverage (Mitev & Nanov, 2022), and mental health decline (Lüdecke & von dem Knesebeck, 2022). Together with the above, the higher education sector of Bulgaria has also undergone changes during the transition process to online learning.…”