Comparative analyses of muscle MRI and muscular function in anti-synthetase syndrome patients and matched controls: a cross-sectional study

Abstract

BackgroundMagnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of thigh muscles is increasingly used to assess disease activity and damage extent in chronic myositis, but the validity of the findings is not clear. Here, the primary aim was to compare thigh MRI findings in patients having chronic myositis associated with anti-synthetase syndrome (ASS) and in matched healthy controls.MethodsCross-sectional analyses of thigh muscle MRI, muscular function and creatinine kinase (CK) were performed in 68 ASS patients (median disease duration 71 months) and 67 controls matched for age and gender. MRI changes associated with disease activity (edema in muscles and fascia) and damage (fatty replacement and muscle volume reduction) were assessed semiquantitatively, giving a total MRI score of 0–78 (total edema 0–42 and total damage 0–36).ResultsASS patients had higher total MRI score than the matched controls (14.1 versus 3.0; p < 0.001) and less muscle strength (p < 0.001). Muscle edema was more frequent in ASS patients than controls (38% versus 12%), as was fatty replacement (42% versus 4%). In ASS patients, we found that the total edema score correlated with CK, but 23% of the patients with normal CK had score > 18. Muscle compartment analyses in ASS patients showed that muscle edema was most pronounced anteriorly, while fatty replacement dominated posteriorly.ConclusionsThis study showed, for the first time, the magnitude of difference in muscle MRI findings between chronic myositis cases and matched controls. In ASS patients, muscle MRI appeared to provide useful complementary information to muscle strength and CK levels in the assessment of myositis.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13075-017-1219-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

MRI of skeletal muscles in patients with idiopathic inflammatory myopathies: characteristic findings and diagnostic performance in dermatomyositis

“…This pattern of MRI findings in MSAs/MAAs-positive patients was partially similar to that in patients with DM. Andersson et al 32 reported that fascial oedema of thigh muscles on MRI was present in 19 of 66 (29%) patients with anti-synthetase syndrome, and that 16 of the 19 patients with anti-synthetase syndrome had known myositis (8 patients with DM and 8 patients with PM). They speculated that the observed MRI pattern with concurrent oedema in muscle and fascia was a feature of active anti-synthetase syndrome, regardless of DM or PM.…”

Update on outcome assessment in myositis

“…Semi-quantitative MRI scoring systems use ordinal scales of varying range to assess fatty infiltration of muscle and muscle oedema, and less frequently muscle atrophy, as well as perifascicular, subcutaneous, soft-tissue, and fascial oedema, but those scoring systems have not been standardised 79 . In studies using semi-quantitative scoring systems, total oedema and damage scores in muscle and fascia correlated with MMT and functional testing in patients with anti-synthetase syndrome 80 , while muscle oedema correlated with PGA, muscle strength by MMT, and CK levels in PM/DM patients 81 , and muscle fatty infiltration correlated with strength and function in IBM patients 82 . A review of MRI semi-quantitative and quantitative scoring methods used to evaluate muscle involvement in patients with IIM was recently published 79 .…”

New Myositis Classification Criteria—What We Have Learned Since Bohan and Peter

“…Muscle MRI has been incorporated in some of the recent criteria set. This technique allows for assessment of muscular inflammation in terms of extent and localization [ 51 •, 52 •, 53 ]. Atrophy and fatty replacement of muscle tissue, a reflection of disease damage, can also be assessed.…”