Community worry about heart disease: a needs survey in the Coalfields and Newcastle areas of the Hunter region

Abstract

A needs survey was administered by mail in the Coalfields area of the Hunter region (a lower socioeconomic area around Cessnock) and in a higher socioeconomic area of Newcastle. The purpose was to assist planning for Coalfields Healthy Heartbeat—a community‐action heart disease prevention program. Response rates from random samples of residents were 435/897 (49 per cent) for the Coalfields and 565/875 (65 per cent) for Newcastle. In both study areas heart attack was ranked eleventh from a list of 17 potential community worries, well below drugs, crime, road safety, the environment, cancer and ‘loss of health’. Coalfields respondents were more worried about all issues on the list than were the residents in Newcastle and were less likely to have heard about recent health promotion campaigns. Coalfields respondents felt that heart disease prevention was the responsibility of the individual, the family, and the medical profession, in that order, and much less the responsibility of local community groups. Results suggest that health promotion strategies incorporating values, language and symbols that are meaningful to distinct subgroups may be more successful than disease‐specific programs aimed at the general population.

Theorising Interventions as Events in Systems

“…Third, when researchers or practitioners stop to ask communities what they are actually interested to work on, rarely does the problem that researchers happen to be focussed on (e.g., heart disease prevention) come top of the list. More acute issues to do with social conditions invariably prevail e.g., drugs, crime, safety, environment, opportunities for children (see Higginbotham et al 1993). Finally, creeping into the literature about health and wellbeing now is a concern for what could be understood as weak prevention, that is, the recognition that modest or negligible effects have almost become the norm in any large scale programs trying to improve health (Zaza et al 2005).…”

An inconvenient truth: why evidence-based policies on obesity are failing Māori, Pasifika and the Anglo working class

“…Like previous campaigns designed to address the issue of obesity via restraint, it has failed. While low household incomes can be directly correlated to poor food choices, there are other examples where household income is not the sole driver of food consumption habits (Higginbotham et al 2010;Rodriguez 2012).…”