Comments on Paper: “Depositional history and provenance of cratonic ‘Purana’ basins in southern India: A multipronged geochronology approach to the Proterozoic Kaladgi and Bhima basins” by Joy et al., 2018. Geological Journal, https://doi.org/10.1002/gj.3415

Abstract

The paper by Joy et al. (2018) contains several generalizations and appears to have followed a flawed analytical technique. We seek clarifications from the authors on specific points to ensure the credibility of the conclusions drawn by them.