Combining Egalitarian Working Lives with Traditional Attitudes: Gender Role Attitudes in Taiwan, Japan, and Korea

Abstract

In a simple theoretical framework, egalitarian gender role attitudes emerge as more and more women participate in the labor market. Most advanced Western nations enjoy relatively gender-egalitarian working environments, and consequently more egalitarian gender attitudes than their East Asian counterparts. Women in East Asian societies, on the other hand, are said to support both the conditions resulting in stagnant female labor-force participation and traditional attitudes toward gender roles. In Taiwan, however, women are more economically active than in two other East Asian societies-Japan and South Korea-even though women in all three societies favor the traditional gender division of labor. Thus, in Taiwan, women experiencing inconsistencies between their active working lives and their traditional values. This study hypothesizes that this inconsistency, or the coexistence of the old and the new, is reflected in the very mind-set of women. Using comparative data from the 2006 East Asian Social Survey, we analyzed the gap between responses to questions on gender attitudes in relation to working conditions, and other general gender role attitudes. We found there were significant differences in the size of these gaps. Taiwanese women expressed more egalitarian views insofar as the questions were concerned with practical economic interests, while they retained their basic traditional attitudes towards gender roles in their homes. This gap is larger in Taiwan than in Japan or South Korea.

Lingering Male Breadwinner Norms as Predictors of Family Satisfaction and Marital Instability

“…In principle, gender roles consist of four dimensions: work (i.e., income earning) versus family (i.e., housework and childcare) roles for each of the two male and female gender groups. The distinction is necessary, because people's attitudes are not consistently symmetrical between the roles of women and men and between the areas of these roles, as widely observed across many societies and often referred to as a stalled gender revolution (England 2010;Knight and Brinton 2017;Lee 2016;Raymo et al 2015;Takeuchi and Tsutsui 2016). For example, strong support for women's gainful employment outside the home may accompany strong support for men's family roles but not necessarily pair with strong support for men being exempted from provider roles.…”

Attitudes of three generations of women toward gender roles

“…Furthermore, the gender role attitudes of human beings can be altered due to the education level of the parents, the mother's work status, family atmosphere, siblings and friends, teachers, textbooks, and the mass media 17 . Particularly, if the education level of mothers is getting higher and if the mother works, children tend to have more egalitarian attitudes 17–19 . In this study, it has been shown that the education level increased in the first, second, and third generations.…”

Taking gender ideologies seriously in climate change mitigation: a case study of Taiwan

“…In the past several decades, Taiwan has seen increases in both female labor force participation and female educational attainment, and the society is Taking gender ideologies seriously moving away from traditional gender ideologies (Ho et al, 2010). Compared with other East Asian countries, Taiwanese people have more egalitarian gender ideologies (Lee, 2017), but Taiwanese women still experience imbalances between family duties and work (Takeuchi and Tsutsui, 2016). Hofstede (1984) defined Taiwan as a low-to-medium masculine society, and an updated data published in 2015 still found that Taiwan is a low-to-medium masculine society (Hofstede, 2015).…”