“…19 In contrast, when doping TiO 2 with A 2+/3+ such as Cr 3+ , Zn 2+ , and In 3+ , it is generally expected to create oxygen vacancies for charge compensation. 8,15,23 To conrm the presence of only Sn 4+ state (without Sn 2+ state) in the structure of the 5% Sn-NTO sample, the Sn 3d prole was observed in detail with binding energies of 486.48 and 494.92 eV, corresponding exclusively to the existence of Sn 4+ , as shown in Fig. 2(c).…”