Collective aspects of privacy in the Twitter social network

Abstract

Preserving individual control over private information is one of the rising concerns in our digital society. Online social networks exist in application ecosystems that allow them to access data from other services, for example gathering contact lists through mobile phone applications. Such data access might allow social networking sites to create shadow profiles with information about non-users that has been inferred from information shared by the users of the social network. This possibility motivates the shadow profile hypothesis: the data shared by the users of an online service predicts personal information of non-users of the service. We test this hypothesis for the first time on Twitter, constructing a dataset of users that includes profile biographical text, location information, and bidirectional friendship links. We evaluate the predictability of the location of a user by using only information given by friends of the user that joined Twitter before the user did. This way, we audit the historical prediction power of Twitter data for users that had not joined Twitter yet. Our results indicate that information shared by users in Twitter can be predictive of the location of individuals outside Twitter. Furthermore, we observe that the quality of this prediction increases with the tendency of Twitter users to share their mobile phone contacts and is more accurate for individuals with more contacts inside Twitter. We further explore the predictability of biographical information of non-users, finding evidence in line with our results for locations. These findings illustrate that individuals are not in full control of their online privacy and that sharing personal data with a social networking site is a decision that is collectively mediated by the decisions of others.

Analyzing gender inequality through large-scale Facebook advertising data

“…Recent reports warn about the possibility that individual Facebook user data was misused by Cambridge Analytica [30], pointing to general concerns about privacy in social media. We share those concerns, in particular with respect to the use of sensitive data in potential conflict with the EU General Data Protection Regulation [31] and regarding the possible construction of shadow profiles of non-users [32,33]. Nevertheless, our results shows that non-personal data, e.g.…”

Information flow reveals prediction limits in online social activity

“…The study of social contagion [9], for example, is predicated on the flow of information over social ties, and has benefited greatly from the availability of massive online social datasets and platforms on which to perform observational and experimental studies [10,11]. Data collected from online social platforms are a boon for researchers [2] but also a source of concern for privacy, as the social flow of predictive information can reveal details on both users and non-users of the platform [5,12,13]. Measuring information flow is challenging, in part due to the complexity of natural language and in part due to the difficulty in defining a 1 arXiv:1708.04575v2 [physics.soc-ph]…”

Analysing Privacy Leakage of Life Events on Twitter

“…Some users take drastic measures and deactivate/delete their accounts to protect themselves from this type of tagging [6]. However, this does not prevent creation of shadow profiles where information about them is shared by their networks [12].…”