Collaborative Governance in Urban Planning: Patterns of Interaction in Curitiba and Montreal

Follador, Débora; Tremblay-Racicot, Fanny; Duarte, Fábio; Carrier, Mario

doi:10.1061/(asce)up.1943-5444.0000642

Cited by 6 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 22 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…A participação pública é o processo de negociação voluntária entre os atores e as organizações mobilizadas para abordar questões coletivas. Para promover o envolvimento positivo e sustentado da comunidade, um processo contínuo de coprodução entre as partes interessadas deve estar no centro do processo de planejamento, resultando em projetos e resultados mais equitativos (Follador, 2021).…”

Section: Apresentação E Análise Dos Dadosunclassified

Plano de Ação e Investimentos Municipais: uma análise a partir da sustentabilidade e da teoria dos sistemas ## Municipal Action Plan and Investments: an analysis based on sustainability and systems theory

Santos

Medeiros

Siena

et al. 2022

AOS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Este artigo busca elaborar um modelo conceitual, apoiado na teoria dos sistemas e nos conceitos de sustentabilidade, que seja uma ferramenta de análise para o Plano de Ação e Investimento (PAI) dos municípios brasileiros. Sendo um importante instrumento para execução das estratégias definidas no plano diretor, o PAI indica projetos e ações estruturantes de um município na busca por um desenvolvimento urbano sustentável. Foi utilizada análise de conteúdo como procedimento metodológico de construção do modelo e análise do PAI. Além do modelo conceitual, se obteve um quadro com as principais categorias consideradas na V Conferência das Cidades. Essas ferramentas apoiaram a análise do PAI do município de Porto Velho e demonstram que há um desequilíbrio entre as dimensões econômicas, sociais e ecológicas nos objetivos das ações e investimentos analisados. Portanto, o modelo se mostrou útil para esta análise e pode ser um importante instrumento para o acompanhamento das principais ações de um município, visto que demonstra esse desequilíbrio de forma sistemática. Porém suas limitações devem ser consideradas, como por exemplo a falta de índices mais consistentes que quantifiquem esse desequilíbrio.ABSTRACTThis article seeks to develop a conceptual model, supported by systems theory and sustainability concepts, which is an analysis tool for the Action and Investment Plan (PAI) of Brazilian municipalities. As an important instrument for implementing the strategies defined in the master plan, the PAI indicates projects and structuring actions of a municipality in the search for sustainable urban development. Content analysis was used as a methodological procedure for building the model and analyzing the PAI. In addition to the conceptual model, a table with the main categories considered in the V Conference of Cities was obtained. These tools supported the analysis of the PAI of the municipality of Porto Velho and demonstrate that there is an imbalance between the economic, social and ecological dimensions in the objectives of the actions and investments analyzed. Therefore, the model proved to be useful for this analysis and can be an important instrument for monitoring the main actions of a municipality, since it demonstrates this imbalance in a systematic way. However, its limitations must be considered, such as the lack of more consistent indices that quantify this imbalance.

show abstract

Section: Apresentação E Análise Dos Dadosunclassified

Plano de Ação e Investimentos Municipais: uma análise a partir da sustentabilidade e da teoria dos sistemas ## Municipal Action Plan and Investments: an analysis based on sustainability and systems theory

Santos

Medeiros

Siena

et al. 2022

AOS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Meninjau sejarah dalam melakukan perencanaan dan manajemen perkotaan yang berbeda pada penerapannya, dari kedua studi kasus mengungkapkan kesamaan yang signifikan, terletak pada tingkat interaksi kolaboratif yang memiliki variasi yang dimiliki antara para pemiliki pemangku kepentingan sesuai dengan jenis aktor yang terkait, arena, serta fase pada melakukan proses perencanaan. Meskipun berdasarkan dengan jumlah yang tebilang kecil untuk studi kasus dan rencana, temuan pada artikel ini setidaknya telah memaparkan tentang mekanisme, factor, dan proses yang dapat membantuk transisi proses perencanaan kota dari praktik informatif/konsultasi ke dalam model tata Kelola kolaboratif (Follador et al, 2021).…”

Section: Pendahuluanunclassified

“…Selain itu juga, artikel yang terkait pada cluster ini juga telah dijelaskan oleh penulis (Follador et al, 2021) pada artikel terpublish dengan judul "Collaborative Governance in Urban Planning: Patterns of Interaction in Curitiba and Montreal" pada artikel ini menjelaskan tentang tata Kelola kolaboratif ialah sebuah gagasan bahwasannya pemerintah, masyarakat sipil, dan actor swasta. Terlepas dari adanya sebuah perbedaan sejarah dalam melakukan perencanaan dan pengelolaan kota, yang dimana dari kedua studi kasus tersebut mengungkapkan adanya kesamaan yang signifikan, yaitu tingkatinteraksi kolaboratif antar pemangku kepentingan yang bervariasi menurut jenis pelaku yang terlibat didalamna, arena, serta fase pada proses perecanaannya.…”

Section: Metodeunclassified

Tata Kelola Kolaboratif Ruang Terbuka Hijau: Sebuah Kajian Pustaka Terstruktur (Systematic Literature Review)

2021

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui tata kelola kolaboratif ruang terbuka hijau sudah berjalan dengan baik namun belum optimal dalam pengimplementasiannya. Penelitian ini menggunakan sistematis literatur review sebagai landasan dasar untuk mempermudah peneliti/mahasiswa agar dapat mengulas dan mengidentifikasi artikel ilmiah secara sistematis dengan langkah-langkah yang telah ditetapkan. Penelitian ini mengungkapkan terdapat 124 artikel yang telah diseleksi dari 378 artikel yang relevan dengan topik yang dibahas. Hasil analisis tersebut menghasilkan 3 cluster yang berbeda dalam 38 konsep yang relevan dengan studi tata kelola kolaboratif ruang terbuka hijau. Dalam penggunaan mode density visualization tidak adanya author yang mendominasi dalam mengkaji pemetaan data author sesuai tema tata kelola kolaboratif ruang terbuka hijau. Semuanya memiliki kedudukan yang sama pentingnya dalam melakukan temuan-temuan yang akan digunakan pada penelitian berikutnya. Penelitian ini mempunyai keterbatasan artikel untuk menunjang literatur review. Dari total keseluruhan artikel yang diperoleh melalui database scopus tidak semuanya memiliki keterkaitan topik yang akan di gunakan untuk melakukan penelitian, sehingga peneliti kesulitan dalam melakukan analisis. Rekomendasi peneliti terhadap penelitian selanjutnya perlunya penggunaan analisis dengan menambah beberapa artikel yang memiliki relevansi yang sama di beberapa sumber artikel ilmiah agar mempermudah dalam melakukan analisis data secara konkrit.

show abstract

“…It makes each border requires special policies, different strategies, and approaches. However, a basic policy, which can serve as an umbrella for all policies and strategies applied nationally to all border areas is required (Follador et al, 2021;Mukhlis & Perdana, 2022). Developing border areas commonly requires a holistic pattern or framework for handling border areas, covering various sectors, and development activities, as well as effective coordination and cooperation from the Central Government to the Regency/City level, which is described in the Collaborative Governance Pattern carried out by the actors involved in handling regional borders between countries (Ansell & Gash, 2008;Balogh et al, 2012;Chang & Meng, 2023).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Collaborative Governance Process in the Indonesia - Malaysia Border Area in North Kalimantan Province

Primanto,

Puspitasari

2023

ARRUS J. Soc. Sci. Hum.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This research aims to analyze and describe the Collaborative Governance process carried out by the Regional Police of North Kalimantan Province conducted by the State Mission in the Field of Border Security between Indonesia and Malaysia. The results of the research indicated that the collaboration process by the North Kalimantan Regional Police with relevant stakeholders in the Republic of Indonesia - Malaysia border area is not optimal. When the North Kalimantan Regional Police carried out a collaboration process with all stakeholders in the Republic of Indonesia - Malaysia border area, this increases a collaboration dynamic to many differences opinion, views, and thought patterns because there are many stakeholders which were involved in maintaining the security of the country's border area. Collaborative actions to maintain the security of the country's borders have been carried out by stakeholders, such as regular meetings, FGDs, and coordination meetings. However, these activities/events are only in such formalities, there is no serious actions in handling Republic of Indonesia - Malaysia border problems in North Kalimantan province. Therefore, the impact resulting from these collaborative activities is not significant in reducing the number of crimes between the two regencies, which directly border Malaysia, namely Malinau and Nunukan.

show abstract

Collaborative Governance in Urban Planning: Patterns of Interaction in Curitiba and Montreal

Cited by 6 publications

References 22 publications

Plano de Ação e Investimentos Municipais: uma análise a partir da sustentabilidade e da teoria dos sistemas ## Municipal Action Plan and Investments: an analysis based on sustainability and systems theory

Plano de Ação e Investimentos Municipais: uma análise a partir da sustentabilidade e da teoria dos sistemas ## Municipal Action Plan and Investments: an analysis based on sustainability and systems theory

Tata Kelola Kolaboratif Ruang Terbuka Hijau: Sebuah Kajian Pustaka Terstruktur (Systematic Literature Review)

Collaborative Governance Process in the Indonesia - Malaysia Border Area in North Kalimantan Province

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About