Collaborative and partnership research for improvement of health and social services: researcher’s experiences from 20 projects

Abstract

BackgroundGetting research into policy and practice in healthcare is a recognised, world-wide concern. As an attempt to bridge the gap between research and practice, research funders are requesting more interdisciplinary and collaborative research, while actual experiences of such processes have been less studied. Accordingly, the purpose of this study was to gain more knowledge on the interdisciplinary, collaborative and partnership research process by investigating researchers’ experiences of and approaches to the process, based on their participation in an inventive national research programme. The programme aimed to boost collaborative and partnership research and build learning structures, while improving ways to lead, manage and develop practices in Swedish health and social services.MethodsInterviews conducted with project leaders and/or lead researchers and documentation from 20 projects were analysed using directed and conventional content analysis.ResultsCollaborative approaches were achieved by design, e.g. action research, or by involving practitioners from several levels of the healthcare system in various parts of the research process. The use of dual roles as researcher/clinician or practitioner/PhD student or the use of education designed especially for practitioners or ‘student researchers’ were other approaches. The collaborative process constituted the area for the main lessons learned as well as the main problems. Difficulties concerned handling complexity and conflicts between different expectations and demands in the practitioner’s and researcher’s contexts, and dealing with human resource issues and group interactions when forming collaborative and interdisciplinary research teams. The handling of such challenges required time, resources, knowledge, interactive learning and skilled project management.ConclusionsCollaborative approaches are important in the study of complex phenomena. Results from this study show that allocated time, arenas for interactions and skills in project management and communication are needed during research collaboration to ensure support and build trust and understanding with involved practitioners at several levels in the healthcare system. For researchers, dealing with this complexity takes time and energy from the scientific process. For practitioners, this puts demands on understanding a research process and how it fits with on-going organisational agendas and activities and allocating time. Some of the identified factors may be overlooked by funders and involved stakeholders when designing, performing and evaluating interdisciplinary, collaborative and partnership research.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12961-018-0322-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Knowledge mobilisation in practice: an evaluation of the Australian Prevention Partnership Centre

“…The challenge of working across epistemic cultures is wellrecognised in the literature (e.g. [53,54]) and previous studies indicate some enduring differences between policymakers and researchers in how they view the same research/policy interactions. For example, Ellen et al [55] found that policy-makers were more likely to emphasise contextual barriers to research use while researchers complained of communicative barriers.…”

Exploring the work and competence of interactive researchers

“…However, there are two recurring patterns. The first pattern is that the researcher should have the ability to actively support learning (Nyström et al, 2018), for example, by creating training Work and competence of interactive researchers courses (Seim et al, 2014) or making contributions to ongoing in-house training programmes (Watson, 2000). Other ways of supporting learning include contributing new perspectives (Holmquist, 2009), serving as a sounding board, or problematising different issues to promote reflection and new lines of thinking (Albinsson, 2015).…”

Advancing Health Services Collaborative and Partnership Research Comment on "Experience of Health Leadership in Partnering with University-Based Researchers in Canada – A Call to ‘Re-imagine’ Research"

“…However, knowledge about research partnerships that address health systems design and organization, or the actual experiences of such processes is still sparse. 8 Bowen and colleagues 9 highlight this trend towards partnership research to address complex challenges in healthcare. They focus on the views of actors on strategic or higher management levels in partner organizations, thereby complementing previous research, which is mostly based on assumptions of researcher-driven initiatives and newly established collaborations.…”