In this paper we show that the critical Eisenstein series of weight 2, E critp 2, is smooth in the eigencurve C(l), where l is a prime. We also show that E critp,ord l 2 is smooth in the full eigencurve C f ull (l) and E critp,ord l 1 ,ord l 2 2 is non-smooth in the full eigencurve C f ull (l 1 l 2 ). Further, we show that, E critp 2, is étale over the weight space in the eigencurve C(l). As a consequence, we show that level lowering conjecture of Paulin fails to hold at E critp,ord l 2 is étale over the weight space in C(ℓ) 9