Cognitive Network Science Reconstructs How Experts, News Outlets and Social Media Perceived the COVID-19 Pandemic

Abstract

This work uses cognitive network science to reconstruct how experts, influential news outlets and social media perceived and reported the news “COVID-19 is a pandemic”. In an exploratory corpus of 1 public speech, 10 influential news media articles on the same news and 37,500 trending tweets, the same pandemic declaration elicited a wide spectrum of perceptions retrieved by automatic language processing. While the WHO adopted a narrative strategy of mitigating the pandemic by raising public concern, some news media promoted fear for economic repercussions, while others channelled trust in contagion containment through semantic associations with science. In Italy, the first country to adopt a nationwide lockdown, social discourse perceived the pandemic with anger and fear, emotions of grief elaboration, but also with trust, a useful mechanism for coping with threats. Whereas news mostly elicited individual emotions, social media promoted much richer perceptions, where negative and positive emotional states coexisted, and where trust mainly originated from politics-related jargon rather than from science. This indicates that social media linked the pandemics to institutions and their intervention policies. Since both trust and fear strongly influence people’s risk-averse behaviour and mental/physical wellbeing, identifying evidence for these emotions is key under a global health crisis. Cognitive network science opens the way to unveiling the emotional framings of massively read news in automatic ways, with relevance for better understanding how information was framed and perceived by large audiences.

Using virtual edges to extract keywords from texts modeled as complex networks

“…Surprisingly, when the weighted versions of the traditional metrics had a poor performance. Our results reinforce the potential of enriching networks in multiple text network applications [12,39,40]. This manuscript is organized as follows: Section II presents a summary of the related works for keyword extraction.…”

Emotional profiling and cognitive networks unravel how mainstream and alternative press framed AstraZeneca, Pfizer and COVID-19 vaccination campaigns

“…The present analysis could be further extended by inspecting into greater detail the emotional fingerprint from different perspectives. An outlet-wise analysis could reveal specific patterns about the positions of the several media sources with respect to the emotional framing of the COVID-19 epidemic 77 or in terms of vaccine hesitancy 5 . Even more interestingly, the same aspects could be assessed on the user-generated comments to the news 9 , 12 , 60 , in order to evaluate the extent to which the emotional content of news titles and bodies are able to influence and propagate among millions of readers.…”

Metodologia da pesquisa em educação e ensino de ciências

“…Na perspectiva da pesquisa em Educação em Ciências, as redes podem ser tratadas como forma de modelagem e análise da complexidade de sistemas conceituais, via análise de redes semânticas (RODRIGUES; CAMILETTI, 2018) ou redes forma mentis (STELLA, 2020). Também podem ser vistas como forma de modelagem e análise de sistemas microssociais da sala de aula, sejam as redes de colaboração entre alunos (SENGUPTA-IRVING, 2014) ou de preferência por certos colegas, o que influencia a transmissão de ideias (SAXE et al, 2009).…”