Cognitive Control Dynamics for Reaching a Satisficing Performance in Complex Dynamic Situations

Abstract

The study of dynamic situations, in which the human operator can exert only partial control (such as in industrial process control, aircraft piloting, or air traffic control), has offered rare opportunities to examine the dynamics of cognitive control. Unlike most of the laboratory approaches to the study of cognition, this kind of study has stressed that several cognitive modes can act in parallel and that the distribution of control among the modes can evolve over time in relation to task requirements and human operator states. This article is a review of the arguments, developed in the literature on dynamic situations and by the authors themselves, in favor of a dynamic adjustment of cognitive control to situational features (integrating both the environment and the human) as a major component of adaptation. The main criterion used by the human operator to adjust cognitive control is situation mastery, as a guarantee that a satisficing performance will be reached with an acceptable quantity of resources. Two main dimensions are proposed to characterize cognitive control modes: the level of abstraction (symbolic/subsymbolic) and the origin (internal-anticipative, external-reactive) of the data used for control. Metacognition is considered as a means to distribute the cognitive control within these dimensions in order to ensure situation mastery. Theoretical, methodological, and practical implications of this perspective on cognitive control dynamics are drawn. From a theoretical viewpoint, the approach stresses the need to consider the cognitive system degrees of freedom to adapt to situations, and that therefore several solutions are possible in order to perform the same task. On the methodological side, the access to the diverse cognitive control modes, to their parallelism, and to the cognitive control dynamics requires new methodological approaches. The practical implications consist in developing support systems that keep the degrees of freedom open for adaptation and in trying to manage consistency.

Cognitive-Adaptation Training for Improving Performance and Stress Management of Air Force Pilots

“…Pilots must continually adjust their level of cognitive involvement depending on both environmental demands and self-perception of efficiency (e.g., perceived fatigue, perceived workload; Hoc & Amalberti, 2007). This continuous regulation of cognitive control allows pilots to adjust performance to changing situations, so as to maintain adequate efficiency and avoid excessive fatigue.…”

The role of algorithm and result comprehensibility of automated scheduling on complacency

“…This balance leads to a satisfactory human performance rather than to an optimal performance (Hoc & Amalberti, 2007). When a function is delegated or allocated to a machine in a multitask situation, attention is shifted to those tasks that are not automated.…”

Cognitive Workload and Psychophysiological Parameters During Multitask Activity in Helicopter Pilots

“…Moreover, when the cognitive cost required by the task became too high and exceeded the participant ' s capacity, " cognitive presence " seemed to disappear and the participant " let go. " 6 In other words, the participant might become overwhelmed by the task or the situation and no longer be able to control or organize his actions in order to adapt and face the situation. Th is is confi rmed by the observed behavior of these two participants.…”