Cognitive and Mood Assessment in Stroke Research

Abstract

Background and Purpose-International guidelines recommend cognitive and mood assessments for stroke survivors; these assessments also have use in clinical trials. However, there is no consensus on the optimal assessment tool(s). We aimed to describe use of cognitive and mood measures in contemporary published stroke trials. Methods-Two independent, blinded assessors reviewed high-impact journals representing: general medicine (nϭ4), gerontology/rehabilitation (nϭ3), neurology (nϭ4), psychiatry (nϭ4), psychology (nϭ4), and stroke (nϭ3) January 2000 to October 2011 inclusive. Journals were hand-searched for relevant, original research articles that described cognitive/mood assessments in human stroke survivors. Data were checked for relevance by an independent clinician and clinical psychologist. Results-Across 8826 stroke studies, 488 (6%) included a cognitive or mood measure. Of these 488 articles, total number with cognitive assessment was 408 (83%) and mood assessment tools 247 (51%). Total number of different assessments used was 367 (cognitive, 300; mood, 67). The most commonly used cognitive measure was Folstein's Mini-Mental State Examination (nϭ180 articles, 37% of all articles with cognitive/mood outcomes); the most commonly used mood assessment was the Hamilton Rating Scale of Depression(nϭ43 [9%]). Conclusions-Cognitive and mood assessments are infrequently used in stroke research. When used, there is substantial heterogeneity and certain prevalent assessment tools may not be suited to stroke cohorts. Research and guidance on the optimal cognitive/mood assessment strategies for clinical practice and trials is required. (Stroke. 2012;43:1678-1680.)

Cognitive and Mood Assessment Tools for Use in Stroke

“…Historically there has been little consistency in the cognitive or mood test employed in stroke 30 and choice of assessment often elicits strong opinion that is not always grounded in evidence. Stroke specific data on the properties of psychological assessment tools has recently become available and we no longer have to extrapolate from studies performed in community or memory clinic settings.…”

Test Accuracy of Short Screening Tests for Diagnosis of Delirium or Cognitive Impairment in an Acute Stroke Unit Setting

“…No tool specifically designed for acute stroke has been described and there is no consensus on the optimal assessment tool for this setting. 5 Detailed neuropsychological assessment may not be practical in a busy acute stroke unit. In practice, a 2-stage technique is often used with initial brief screening by a nonspecialist used to select those subjects who may need more detailed assessment.…”

The effects of music listening interventions on cognition and mood post-stroke: a systematic review

“…In this situation, meta-analysis can have utility but the heterogeneity across studies precluded any attempt at meaningful summary analysis. We note the inconsistency in outcome assessments employed to describe mood and cognition, this has been described in many other areas of stroke research [38]. Even if we had been able to pool data, the total number of participants across all the available studies was less than would be seen in a typical phase III study of a pharmacological intervention in stroke or dementia.…”