Co-Benefits Analysis of Buildings Based on Different Renewal Strategies: The Emergy-Lca Approach

Abstract

Many cities have encountered challenges associated with rapid urban development, population growth and aging, in which urban renewal has become a promising option. Different renewal strategies, such as redevelopment, refurbishment and conservation, not only contributes to quality improvement and energy consumption reduction of dilapidated urban area, but also to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions mitigation. Such integrated benefits are often termed as co-benefits. However, choosing the most co-benefits strategy to adopt requires a holistic understanding of social-economic and environmental aspects, which has been less reported in the existing literature. Under such circumstance, this article aims to shed light on the co-benefits of different renewal strategies by adopting the Emergy-Life cycle assessment method. Then, the method is applied to one case study of the refurbishment of an educational building located in Chongqing, China. Resource allocation, CO2 emissions and emergy-based indicators are calculated to assess the co-benefits during a 60-year research period, to compare the impacts of the complete demolition followed by a new one (rebuilding strategy) and the refurbishing of the existing building (refurbishment strategy). The case study shows that the annual emergy in the O&M phase of rebuilding strategy and refurbishment strategy were lower than existing building. Rebuilding and refurbishment strategies released approximately 59.1% and 80.6%, respectively, of the total CO2 emissions that would be produced by the existing building. The results reveal that substantial environmental benefits can be obtained in both the refurbishment and rebuilding strategies. On the other hand, it can be concluded that the emergy yield ratio (EYR) for the rebuilding strategy is higher than refurbishment strategy, which demonstrate the better performance of refurbishment considering that less resources are required to generate greater benefits. In addition, the value of environmental loading ratio (ELR) and emergy sustainability index (ESI) also suggests that the refurbishment strategy performs better from the perspective of the environment. Thereby, the refurbishment strategy is more suitable than the rebuilding strategy. Findings from this study can be useful to urban planners and decision-makers in choosing the most suitable strategy to improve the quality of existing buildings.

Ferramenta ACV aplicada em retrofit de edificações: uma revisão sistemática

“…ENTAC2022 -Ambiente Construído: Resiliente e Sustentável Quadro 1: Caracterização dos estudos de caso Referência Tipo de edificação Localização Natureza de intervenção [11] Edificação industrial Itália Reforma de envelope [12] Residencial multifamiliar Alemanha Reforma de envelope [7] Residencial unifamiliar Portugal Remodelação de cobertura [4] Misto -Comercial e residencial China Remodelação diversa [1] Edificação educacional -Escola Turquia Remodelação estrutural [6] Residencial multifamiliar Portugal Remodelação estrutural [23] Edificação industrial Espanha Remodelação estrutural [27] Residencial unifamiliar Canada Retrofit de energia [18] Residencial multifamiliar Suíça Retrofit de envelope e sistema de aquecimento [14] Edificação educacional -Universidade Itália Retrofit de sistema térmico [20] Edificação institucional -Pública Bélgica Retrofit de sistema térmico [25] Residencial multifamiliar Canadá Retrofit de sistema térmico [3] Residencial unifamiliar e multifamiliar Portugal Retrofit de sistema térmico [16] Residência unifamiliar Portugal Retrofit de sistema térmico de cobertura [15] Residência unifamiliar Portugal Retrofit de toda construção [5] Residencial multifamiliar Noruega Retrofit de toda construção [17] Edificação educacional -Não especificada China Retrofit de toda construção [19] Edificação comercial Estados Unidos…”

A Sustainability Analysis Based on the LCA–Emergy–Carbon Emission Approach in the Building System

“…As a special form of architecture, highway engineering has also been surveyed through emergy evaluation [48]. By relying on an LCA-Emergy approach, different renewal strategies for building systems are demonstrated, so as to select a better renewal strategy [49].…”

A Study on Ecological Emergy and Carbon-Emissions-Coupling Sustainability of Building Systems

“…As this study involves the emergy analysis of the entire life cycles of building systems, relevant research regarding the relationship between building systems and LCA-emergy methods has been reviewed. Currently, there is limited research in this area, mainly focusing on the emergy analysis of the entire life cycles of building systems [19], renewal design strategies for building systems [20], and the impact of the energy embodied in building materials on the sustainability of building systems [21].…”