Clustering Approach toward Large Truck Crash Analysis

Abstract

Heterogeneity of crash data masks the underlying crash patterns and perplexes crash analysis. This paper aims to explore an advanced high-dimensional clustering approach to investigate heterogeneity in large datasets. Detailed records of crashes involving large trucks occurring in the state of Florida between 2007 and 2016 were examined to identify truck crash patterns and significant conditions contributing to the patterns. The block clustering method was applied to more than 220,000 crash records with nearly 200 attributes. The analysis showed promising results in segmenting a large heterogeneous dataset into meaningful subgroups (with 95.72% average degree of homogeneity for selected blocks). The goodness of fit for clustering methods is evaluated and both integrated completed likelihood (ICL) and pseudo-likelihood values improved significantly (20.8% and 21.1% respectively). Attribute clustering showed distinct characteristics for each cluster. Crash clustering revealed significant differences among the clusters and suggested that this crash dataset could be portioned as same-direction, opposing-direction, and single-vehicle crashes. Individual blocks defined by both row and column clustering were further investigated to better understand the contribution set of conditions that lead to large truck crashes. Major features for each of the three major types of crashes were analyzed, which may provide additional insights to develop potential countermeasures and strategies that target specific segments. The clustering approach could be used as a preanalysis method to identify homogeneous subgroups for further analysis, which will help enhance the effectiveness of safety programs.

Acceptance of Full Driving Automation: Personally Owned and Shared-Use Concepts

“…This number increases by more than 60% for Boston and Washington D.C. which are ranked as the most congested two cities in the United States (“INRIX 2018 Global Traffic Scorecard,” 2018). Researchers have argued that automated driving systems (levels 3-5; SAE International, 2018) have the potential to resolve some of the current transportation challenges and to improve road safety and efficiency (Anderson et al, 2014; Arvin, Kamrani, Khattak, & Rios-Torres, 2018; Bengler, Dietmayer, Maurer, & Winner, 2014; Litman, 2017; Rahimi, Azimi, Asgari, & Jin, 2019).…”

Injury Severity Analysis for Large Truck-Involved Crashes: Accounting for Heterogeneity

“…Clustering methods relax the restrictions imposed by traditional methods and have been applied by numerous studies in the past few years. These methods include support vector machine ( 61 – 63 ), K-means clustering ( 61 , 64 , 65 ), classification trees ( 37 , 38 , 66 , 67 ), block clustering ( 11 ), and latent class models ( 15 , 68 ).…”

Enhancing the Analysis of Software Failures in Cloud Computing Systems with Deep Learning

“…As in the work by Arunajadai et al [26], the matrix is used for grouping the failure modes using clustering algorithms, such as the K-means. Rahimi et al [30] analyzed a large dataset of truck crash data, based on police reports about the driver, vehicle, crash, and citation information. They address the problem of high-dimensionality spaces, by adopting block clustering to investigate heterogeneity in the crash dataset.…”