Cluster Analysis of IR Thermography Data for Differentiating Glass Types in Historical Leaded-Glass Windows

Abstract

Infrared thermography is a fast, non-destructive and contactless testing technique which is increasingly used in heritage science. The aim of this study was to assess the ability of infrared thermography, in combination with a data clustering approach, to differentiate between the different types of historical glass that were included in a colorless leaded-glass windows during previous restoration interventions. Inspection of the thermograms and the application of two data mining techniques on the thermal data, i.e., k-means clustering and hierarchical clustering, allowed identifying different groups of window panes that show a different thermal behavior. Both clustering approaches arrive at similar groupings of the glass with a clear separation of three types. However, the lead cames that hold the glass panes appear to have a substantial impact on the thermal behavior of the surrounding glass, thus preventing classification of the smallest glass panes. For the larger panes, this was not a critical issue as the center of the glass remained unaffected. Subtle visual color differences between panes, implying a variation in coloring metal ions, was not always distinguished by IRT. Nevertheless, data clustering assisted infrared thermography shows potential as an efficient and swift method for documenting the material intervention history of leaded-glass windows during or in preparation of conservation treatments.

Review of the efficacy of infrared thermography for screening infectious diseases with applications to COVID-19

“…Several studies have been conducted to investigate the effects of various experimental parameters on thermal measurement accuracy. The United States Food and Drug Administration 40 quantitatively compared two moderately priced commercial IRTs in various environmental conditions. The study found that the temperature, humidity, and type of data processing methods significantly affected IRT results.…”

Comparison of four mobile, non‐invasive diagnostic techniques for differentiating glass types in historical leaded windows: MA‐XRF, UV–Vis–NIR, Raman spectroscopy and IRT

“…Further processing of the data, such as application of clustering algorithms, might result in more reliable results, based on the entire time sequence of recorded thermograms. [ 34 ]…”

“…The ensuing thermal anomalies were investigated by acquiring a series of thermograms at a frame rate of 10 Hz. [ 34–37 ]…”

INFRA REDable. Thermography for the diagnosis and conservation of frescoed walls: the case of the Templar Church of San Bevignate

“…• masonry quality and texture; • connections among structural elements; • structural irregularities or defects; • presence of damages and phenomena of degradation. In this context the use of advanced close-range non-destructive techniques, such as Infrared Thermography (IRT) can already be profitably used for the detection of conservation issues (e.g., open fractures, unstable ledges) that can lead to deterioration phenomena (Hillen 2020, Meola 2016, Enshaeian 2021). These techniques, when combined with traditional methods (e.g.…”