Closer scrutiny of cosmic ray proton energy losses

Abstract

The percent-level precision attained by modern cosmic ray (CR) observations motivates reaching a comparable or better control of theoretical uncertainties. Here we focus on energy-loss processes affecting low-energy CR protons (∼0.1–5 GeV), where the experimental errors are small and collisional effects play a comparatively larger role with respect to collisionless transport ones. We study three aspects of the problem: (i) We quantitatively assess the role of the nuclear elastic cross section, for the first time, providing analytical formulas for the stopping power and inelasticity; (ii) We discuss the error arising from treating both elastic and pion production inelastic interactions as continuous energy loss processes, as opposed to catastrophic ones. The former is the approximation used in virtually all modern numerical calculations; (iii) We consider subleading effects such as relativistic corrections, radiative and medium processes in ionization energy losses. Our analysis reveals that neglecting (i) leads to errors close to 1%, notably around and below 1 GeV, neglecting (ii) leads to errors reaching about 3% within the considered energy range, (iii) contributes to a minor effect, gauged at the level of 0.1%. Consequently, while (iii) can currently be neglected, (ii) warrants consideration, and we also recommend incorporating (i) into computations. We conclude with some perspectives on further steps to be taken towards a high-precision goal of theoretical CR predictions regarding the treatment of energy losses. Published by the American Physical Society 2024