Clinical research ethics review process in Lebanon: efficiency and functions of research ethics committees – results from a descriptive questionnaire-based study

Abstract

BackgroundClinical trials conducted in Lebanon are increasing. However, little is known about the performance of research ethics committees (RECs) in charge of reviewing the research protocols. This study aimed to assess the level of adherence to the ethics surrounding the conduct of clinical trials and perceptions of team members regarding roles of the RECs during the conduct of clinical trials in Lebanon. The research question was: Are RECs adherent to the ethics surrounding the conduct of clinical trials (chapters II and IV in ‘Standards and Operational Guidance for Ethics Review of Health-related Research with Human Participants’ in Lebanon?’MethodsThis was a quantitative and descriptive questionnaire-based study conducted among RECs of university hospitals in Lebanon. The questionnaire had to be completed online and included general questions in addition to items reflecting the different aspects of a REC performance and effectiveness. All the questionnaire was assigned a total score of 175 points. General information and questions assigned point values/scores were analysed using descriptive statistics: frequency and percentage, mean score ± standard deviation.ResultsTen RECs participated in the study (52 persons: four chairs, one vice-president, 47 ordinary members). Forty-seven (90.4%) had previous experience with clinical research and 30 (57.7%) had a diploma or had done a training in research ethics. Forty-one percent confirmed that they were required to have a training in research ethics. All RECs had a policy for disclosing and managing potential conflicts of interest for its members, but 71.8% of participants reported the existence of such a policy for researchers. Thirty-three point three percent reported that the RECs had an anti-bribery policy. The questionnaire mean score was 129.6 ± 22.3/175 points reflecting thus an excellent adherence to international standards.ConclusionInadequate training of REC members and the lack of anti-bribery policies should be resolved to improve their performance.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13063-017-2397-2) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Ethical issues in consenting older adults: academic researchers and community perspectives

“…In the current study, more than a third of the researchers did not have training in research ethics. Inadequate research ethics training was demonstrated in several studies conducted in developing countries . A survey of the faculty members at Cairo University in Egypt showed that almost half of them never attended a course in research ethics .…”

“…Inadequate research ethics training was demonstrated in several studies conducted in developing countries. [24][25][26] A survey of the faculty members at Cairo University in Egypt showed that almost half of them never attended a course in research ethics. [27] Giving the gaps in research ethics in the Middle East countries, [26] it is clear that research ethics training is necessary to improve ethical standards in the conduct of academic and biomedical research.…”

Development of national dietary and lifestyle guidelines for pregnant women in Lebanon

“…Using emails (as in the case of the Delphi), participants may feel that their input is restricted to their respective fields of specialties. Using the Delphi technique requires a high motivation level on behalf of the participants to respond to their emails (Health Knowledge, 2016). In Lebanon, participation and response rate using emails are less common, and response rate could constitute a barrier (Atallah et al, 2018; Bizri et al, 2020), a context that may raise concern of lack of contribution of participants. The latter cited as a main reason for using the NGT (Manera et al, 2019).…”

Developing Quality and Efficiency of Institutional Review Board Review Under a Human Research Protection Program at a Leading Hospital in Central Southern China: A Descriptive Analysis of the First Three Years

“…Clinical research activity involving human subjects is increasing in developing countries (Atallah et al, 2018; Normile, 2008). In today's research environment, Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) are fundamental to the protection of human research participants (Rwabihama et al, 2010).…”