Clinical psychologists do politics: Attitudes and reactions of Israeli psychologists toward the political

Abstract

This article presents an analysis of a survey among Israeli clinical psychologists, examining their attitudes towards diverse political issues. The survey involved the distribution of 600 questionnaires, 115 of which were returned. Within this framework, psychologists were asked to relate to questions regarding political issues in psychotherapy and the ways of dealing with them, socio‐political issues in psychology studies and training processes, socio‐political involvement of psychologists as citizens or as professionals, and more. This inquiry enabled the current state of affairs to be portrayed with regard to common professional‐political conceptions and stances toward political aspects of psychotherapeutic work. The survey's findings point to a divide within the Israeli psychologist community, as expressed by divergent and contradictory opinions that arise in response to a sizable portion of the issues examined. It is quite possible that this rift marks a process of change and indicates the decline of the conservative psychodynamic conceptual system. This theoretical perspective had, up until recently, a hegemonic position within the Israeli psychotherapeutic milieu. In most cases this standpoint was applied in a dogmatic manner, justifying a passive social‐political stance in the name of anonymity and neutrality. It appears that still, today, this epistemic position is predominant within the Israeli psychotherapeutic culture. However, nowadays, a large minority of Israeli clinical psychologists seems to be sensitive to different political aspects of psychotherapy and favourable toward working in a politically informed and socially responsible manner. As political issues are almost entirely absent from psychology academic programs and clinical training processes, there is much confusion and helplessness as to how such issues and phenomena should be treated in therapy. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Conducting psychotherapy in the Trump era: Therapists’ perspectives on political self‐disclosure, the therapeutic alliance, and politics in the therapy room

“…Despite growing interest in investigating both patients’ and therapists’ perspectives on the therapeutic process, there is still a very limited body of research on the effects of politics on psychotherapy processes, with a lack of empirical research on the topic (McCarthy & Saks, ; Milton & Legg, ). Generally, politics is rarely discussed in clinical training programs and psychology academic programs (Avissar, ). This is quite surprising given the significant effect of the political climate on patients and therapists’ everyday lives, especially on patients from marginalized and disadvantaged communities who are most affected by shifts in policy and civil rights legislation.…”

“If she had helped me to solve the problem at my workplace, she would have cured me”: A critical discourse analysis of a mental health intake

“…The hegemonic psychotherapeutic discourse has been criticized for emphasizing intrapersonal processes while ignoring—or at best underestimating—the socio-cultural context in which the individual lives and through which suffering emerges (Avissar, 2009; Cushman, 1990; Masson, 1988; Nakash et al., 2009; Parker, 1999; Prilleltensky et al., 2008). This is despite the accumulation of research attesting to the impact of social determinants of mental health inequities (Alegria et al., 2009; Braveman et al., 2011; Nakash et al., 2012, 2013, 2014a).…”

Inside and/or Outside? Working Sensitively with Political Material in Psychotherapy

“…A growing tendency to include the political in therapeutic discourse can be observed from the late 1980s (Avissar, ). This has found expression in theoretical and conceptual changes in relation to therapy; in growing recognition of the role of political variables in psychotherapy; and in increasing reference to the possible effects on political reality of psychology, including its therapeutic branches.…”