Clinical performance among recent graduates in nine low‐ and middle‐income countries

Abstract

SummaryObjectivesRecent studies have identified large and systematic deficits in clinical care in low‐income countries that are likely to limit health gains. This has focused attention on effectiveness of pre‐service education. One approach to assessing this is observation of clinical performance among recent graduates providing care. However, no studies have assessed performance in a standard manner across countries. We analysed clinical performance among recently graduated providers in nine low‐ or middle‐income countries.MethodsService Provision Assessments from Haiti, Kenya, Malawi, Namibia, Nepal, Rwanda, Senegal, Tanzania, and Uganda were used. We constructed a Good Medical Practice Index that assesses completion of essential clinical actions using direct observations of care (range 0–1), calculated index scores by country and clinical cadre, and assessed the role of facility and clinical characteristics using regression analysis.ResultsOur sample consisted of 2223 clinicians with at least one observation of care. The Good Medical Practice score for the sample was 0.50 (SD = 0.20). Nurses and midwives had the highest score at 0.57 (SD = 0.20), followed by associate clinicians at 0.43 (SD = 0.18), and physicians at 0.42 (SD = 0.16). The average national performance varied from 0.63 (SD = 0.18) in Uganda to 0.39 (SD = 0.17) in Nepal, persisting after adjustment for facility and clinician characteristics.ConclusionsThese results show substantial gaps in clinical performance among recently graduated clinicians, raising concerns about models of clinical education. Competency‐based education should be considered to improve quality of care in LMICs. Observations of care offer important insight into the quality of clinical education.

Learning from changes concurrent with implementing a complex and dynamic intervention to improve urban maternal and perinatal health in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, 2011-2019

“…Exploring the feasibility of building capacity of ward in-charges to conduct introductory training for new staff, exploring modalities for introducing low-dose, high-frequency on-the-job training, as well as investing in preservice education to improve health providers’ competencies are recommended. 45 46 …”

Scaling Up Improved Inpatient Treatment of Severe Malnutrition: Key Factors and Experiences From South Africa, Bolivia, Malawi, and Ghana

“…The poor clinical performance of recent graduates in LMICs raises concerns about gaps in knowledge and models of pre-service education. 38,39 Medical and nursing curricula rarely include malnutrition leading to a reliance on in-service training. However, the goal must be to realign pre-service training so that it is fit-for-purpose and competency-based for effective practice.…”

Postgraduate medical education: The history and development of competency-based training program in Nepal

“…68 In observation of recently graduated clinicians from nine LMIC, Nepal has shown poor performance; raising concerns about the models of clinical education and need for CBME. 4,69 Competence is the ability to perform a specific task to yield desirable outcomes based on: knowledge (understanding facts and procedures), skills (capacity to perform specific actions), abilities (based on previous experience to perform a new task), and traits (personality characteristics to respond in a certain way). 68 Measurement of competency is based on competence (can do) and performance (does).…”