Clinical excellence in nephrology: Examples from the published literature

Abstract

BackgroundProvision of exceptional medical care is a goal for the medical profession because this is what the public needs and deserves. Academic medical centers that value excellent clinicians may have the best chance to recruit and retain these faculty members. When our institution hoped to launch the Miller Coulson Academy of Clinical Excellence to measure and reward master clinicians, a critical first step was to use rigorous methods to develop a definition of clinical excellence. Published papers have illustrated that this general definition of clinical excellence is applicable to fields of psychiatry, cardiology, and pediatrics.SummaryIn this manuscript, we apply the definition of clinical excellence to nephrology. Using the same framework, we reviewed the literature to find clinical cases and exemplary nephrologists that highlight the specific domains. This collection of reports in nephrology illustrates that the definition of clinical excellence set forth by the Miller Coulson Academy is highly applicable to physicians caring for individuals with kidney disease. Relating the definition of clinical excellence to renal medicine is worthwhile in that it can help to exemplify the model to which physicians and trainees may seek to aspire.Key messageMany examples of clinical excellence in renal medicine can be found in the published medical literature. The domains of clinical excellence, described by the Miller-Coulson Academy of Clinical Excellence, apply very well to the field of nephrology.

The telemedicine experience: using principles of clinical excellence to identify disparities and optimize care

“…Traits such as empathy and compassion allow physicians to display professionalism, upholding the highest standard of care. [ 13 ] While this study did not directly assess humanism, the high level of patient satisfaction suggests that humanism can be conveyed during telemedicine encounters.…”

“…Diagnostic acumen describes the analytical ability of clinicians to reach a correct diagnosis. [ 13 ] This typically requires the provider to first gather information from a patient's verbal history. In many cases the physical examination is then used to confirm the diagnosis before creating an appropriate treatment plan.…”

Clinical Excellence in Otolaryngology‐Head and Neck Surgery: Examples from the Published Literature

“…The MCACE's domains have proven to be useful in other medical fields as a framework for the recognition of clinical excellence 6–12 . These domains are also applicable to OHNS.…”

“…From this process, clinical excellence was defined as: Achieving a level of mastery in the following areas as they relate to patient care: Communication and interpersonal skills Professionalism and humanism Diagnostic acumen Skillful negotiation of the healthcare system Knowledge Scholarly approach to clinical practice Exhibiting a passion for patient care and modeling clinical excellence Collaborating with investigators to advance science and discovery. The last two components of this definition are more relevant to an academic medical setting, while the other domains are relevant across all clinical settings. Published papers have illustrated that this definition of clinical excellence is applicable to a variety of medical fields, including psychiatry, pediatrics, physical medicine and rehabilitation, infectious disease, palliative care, nephrology, and hospital medicine 6–12 …”

Clinical Excellence in Palliative Care: Examples From the Published Literature

“…Research has characterized the core elements of clinical excellence in academic medicine, and subsequent scholarly work has applied these domains to a wide range of medical disciplines-from cardiology to psychiatry to physical medicine and rehabilitation and beyond. [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8] Founded in 2009, the Miller-Coulson Academy of Clinical Excellence (MCACE) at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine recognizes and promotes excellence in patient care for the benefit of the patients and communities served by the institution. 9 Through varied programs targeted for patients, medical students, residents, and practicing clinicians, the MCACE highlights and perpetuates the highest standards of clinical excellence.…”