Clinical ethics committees in nursing homes: what good can they do? Analysis of a single case consultation

Abstract

Background: Ought nursing homes to establish clinical ethics committees (CECs)? An answer to this question must begin with an understanding of how a clinical ethics committee might be beneficial in a nursing home context – to patients, next of kin, professionals, managers, and the institution. With the present article, we aim to contribute to such an understanding. Aim: We ask, in which ways can clinical ethics committees be helpful to stakeholders in a nursing home context? We describe in depth a clinical ethics committee case consultation deemed successful by stakeholders, then reflect on how it was helpful. Research design: Case study using the clinical ethics committee’s written case report and self-evaluation form, and two research interviews, as data. Participants and research context: The nursing home’s ward manager and the patient’s son participated in research interviews. Ethical considerations: Data were collected as part of an implementation study. Clinical ethics committee members and interviewed stakeholders consented to study participation, and also gave specific approval for the publication of the present article. Findings/results: Six different roles played by the clinical ethics committee in the case consultation are described: analyst, advisor, support, moderator, builder of consensus and trust, and disseminator. Discussion: The case study indicates that clinical ethics committees might sometimes be of help to stakeholders in moral challenges in nursing homes. Conclusions: Demanding moral challenges arise in the nursing home setting. More research is needed to examine whether clinical ethics committees might be suitable as ethics support structures in nursing homes and community care.

Clinical Observation of MRI Scanning Combined with Clinical Nursing for Surgical Breast Cancer Patients

“…In China, more than 270,000 new cases are reported each year, making it the number one cancer for women and the sixth leading cause of death for women. Studies show that by 2050, 3.2 million people worldwide will be diagnosed with breast cancer each year [ 1 ]. The incidence rate and mortality rate of breast cancer in China are lower than the world average.…”

Establishing Clinical Ethics Committees in Primary Care: A Study from Norwegian Municipal Care

“…Both staff and top-level managers might expect them to handle and decide on challenges and value conflicts. Considering these expectations and responsibilities the CEC might be a particularly welcome support for this group (Magelssen & Karlsen, 2021).…”

Strategies to mitigate moral distress as reported by eldercare professionals

“…Clients in elderly services are often afflicted with multiple illnesses and health conditions affecting their functional abilities. In the case of elderly individuals with cognitive impairments, ethical questions linked to autonomy are accentuated (Bozzaro et al, 2018 ; Magelssen & Karlsen, 2022 ; Marks et al, 2021 ; Podgorica et al, 2021 ). Previous studies have also shown that conflicts around patient autonomy are especially prominent in home care (Heggestad et al, 2021 ; Lindberg et al, 2023 ; Öresland et al, 2008 ).…”