Clinical assessment is a neglected component of outbreak preparedness: evidence from refugee camps in Greece

Abstract

BackgroundRefugees may have an increased vulnerability to infectious diseases, and the consequences of an outbreak are more severe in a refugee camp. When an outbreak is suspected, access to clinical information is critical for investigators to verify that an outbreak is occurring, to determine the cause and to select interventions to control it. Experience from previous outbreaks suggests that the accuracy and completeness of this information is poor. This study is the first to assess the adequacy of clinical characterisation of acute medical illnesses in refugee camps. The objective is to direct improvements in outbreak identification and management in this vulnerable setting.MethodsWe collected prospective data in 13 refugee camps in Greece. We passively observed consultations where patients presented with syndromes that might warrant inclusion into an existing syndromic surveillance system and then undertook a structured assessment of routine clinical data collection to examine the extent to which key clinical parameters required for an outbreak response were ascertained and then documented.ResultsA total of 528 patient consultations were included. The most common presenting condition was an acute respiratory illness. Clinicians often made a comprehensive clinical assessment, especially for common syndromes of respiratory and gastrointestinal conditions, but documented their findings less frequently. For fewer than 5% of patients were a full set of vital signs ascertained and so the severity of patient illnesses was largely unknown. In only 11% of consultations was it verified that a patient who met the case criteria for syndromic surveillance reporting based on an independent assessment was reported into the system.DiscussionOpportunities exist to strengthen clinical data capture and recording in refugee camps, which will produce a better calibrated and directed public health response.ConclusionInformation of significant utility for outbreak response is collected at the clinical interface and we recommend improving how this information is recorded and linked into surveillance systems.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12916-018-1015-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Key Dimensions for the Prevention and Control of Communicable Diseases in Institutional Settings: A Scoping Review to Guide the Development of a Tool to Strengthen Preparedness at Migrant Holding Centres in the EU/EEA

“…Human-to-human transmitted and food and waterborne infections have been described in a variety of institutions, while skin infections have been described in correctional and migration settings. These findings are consistent with the results of syndromic surveillance in migration centres in Italy [ 77 , 78 ] and Greece [ 79 , 80 ], that have identified signs/symptoms of scabies, respiratory tract infections, and gastrointestinal infections as the most frequently reported syndromes.…”

Population dynamics, pathogen detection and insecticide resistance of mosquito and sand fly in refugee camps, Greece

“…Essential steps for the prevention and control of leishmaniasis transmission in the refugee camps include systematic active (upon consent) and passive detection of leishmaniasis in the refugee populations, effective treatment of infected patients, detection-treatment and removal of infected dogs from the camp grounds, and the replacement of tents and rubber halls with insect proof shelters. Despite the fact that the leishmaniasis burden is high in refugee populations in the Eastern Mediterranean region [43,45], refugee population screening and clinical assessment for Leishmania infections is limited in European host countries [48,49]. On the contrary, a positive step improving living conditions is an accommodation scheme providing rented housing to a small number of vulnerable asylum-seekers and refugees in Greece [50].…”

‘A Cross Sectional Survey of Sociodemographic Characteristics, Primary Care Health Needs and Living Conditions of Asylum-Seekers Living in a Greek Reception Centre.’

“…The high rates of self-reported respiratory and diarrhoeal disease in our study population suggests a need for more rigorous infectious disease surveillance and management. In the event of an epidemic, it is unlikely there would be su cient resources to respond quickly and effectively (25).…”