Climate Resilience of Internally-Insulated Historic Masonry Assemblies: Comparison of Moisture Risk under Current and Future Climate Scenarios

Abstract

The conservation of cultural heritage built of historical brick masonry alongside meeting targets in energy reduction will most likely require widespread installation of internal wall insulation (IWI). In London, traditional buildings (pre-1919) make up 40% of the existing stock and insulating from the interior is a likely retrofit solution for solid brick walls. Adding insulation may introduce a higher risk to moisture accumulation and consequences such as mould growth and material decay. To investigate resilience to future moisture loads, three interior insulation assemblies (conforming to two U-value guidelines) were simulated in DELPHIN under reference, near-future (2040), and far-future climate (2080) scenarios. Calcium silicate, phenolic foam, and wood fibre assemblies were simulated. The reference year climate file was compiled from observed data and future files developed using the UK Climate Projections 2018 (UKCP18). Assemblies were evaluated for moisture accumulation, mould growth risk, and freeze-thaw (FT) risk. Results show low-to-medium risks in 2040 and high risks in 2080, assemblies of higher absorptivity and thinner insulation comparatively performing best. The calcium silicate assembly fared best for moisture performance; however, all assemblies will be subject to high moisture risk levels in the far future and responsible retrofits must take this and alternative design solutions into account.

Degradation of brick masonry walls in Europe and the Mediterranean: Advantages of a response-based analysis to study climate change

“…Flyen et al analysed the changes in fungal decay in historical structures in Norway [26]. Lu et al evaluated the projected change in moisture behaviour of a couple of interior insulated wall assemblies in London [27].…”

Freeze-thaw risk in solid masonry: The difference between a climate-based and response-based analysis to study climate change.

“…one solid masonry wall with and one without interior insulation). However, the hygrothermal performance of building envelopes, as well as the change in degradation risk due to CC, is highly sensitive to parameter variations [7], [12].…”

Freeze-Thaw Risk in Solid Masonry Walls: Impact of Climate Change over Europe and the Mediterranean subjected to RCP 4.5

“…Most of these studies are based on climate variables alone, even though there is no linear relation between climate variables and the hygrothermal response of building components. The results of Heat Air Moisture (HAM) simulations are only included in a handful of studies [5], [6]. However, these studies are often limited to one of two locations, and they are often limited to a low number of variations (e.g.…”