Clickstream Data Yields High-Resolution Maps of Science

Abstract

BackgroundIntricate maps of science have been created from citation data to visualize the structure of scientific activity. However, most scientific publications are now accessed online. Scholarly web portals record detailed log data at a scale that exceeds the number of all existing citations combined. Such log data is recorded immediately upon publication and keeps track of the sequences of user requests (clickstreams) that are issued by a variety of users across many different domains. Given these advantages of log datasets over citation data, we investigate whether they can produce high-resolution, more current maps of science.MethodologyOver the course of 2007 and 2008, we collected nearly 1 billion user interactions recorded by the scholarly web portals of some of the most significant publishers, aggregators and institutional consortia. The resulting reference data set covers a significant part of world-wide use of scholarly web portals in 2006, and provides a balanced coverage of the humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences. A journal clickstream model, i.e. a first-order Markov chain, was extracted from the sequences of user interactions in the logs. The clickstream model was validated by comparing it to the Getty Research Institute's Architecture and Art Thesaurus. The resulting model was visualized as a journal network that outlines the relationships between various scientific domains and clarifies the connection of the social sciences and humanities to the natural sciences.ConclusionsMaps of science resulting from large-scale clickstream data provide a detailed, contemporary view of scientific activity and correct the underrepresentation of the social sciences and humanities that is commonly found in citation data.

The Challenges of Journal Startup in the Digital Era

“…As studies in big data show, a researcher armed only with an internet connection and a library subscription can roam far and wide, from journal to journal, and in so doing can add to the bending of the organizational structure of the academy [13].…”

“…Perhaps the first point to be made about INQUIRE [13] is that it has not yet achieved high visibility within the university, and in large measure that relates to the potential burden on faculty and staff time which is a significant deterrent to participation. Although it is taken for granted that we now live in a blogging culture in which anyone can create opinion, relatively few choose to.…”

A multi-metric approach for research evaluation

“…This group also makes use of clickstream data, virtual trails of users surfing the Internet [15]. Following these ideas Wan et al [16] studied download data from the CNKI database, a large Chinese full-text database, leading to a download immediacy index.…”

Going beyond Citations: SERUM — a new Tool Provided by a Network of Libraries

“…Like MESUR, SERUM also aims to obtain usage data from the publishers in order to derive usage metrics from these. However, other than MESUR it is neither the objective of SERUM to create a complex semantic model of the scholarly communication process nor to produce science maps (Bollen et al, 2009) on the basis of the established reference data set. The maps and ranking services available from 'MESUR: science maps and rankings from large-scale usage data' are highly complex and only insightful for a minority of experts.…”