Circulations of Law: Cosmopolitan Elites, Global Repertoires, Local Vernaculars

Abstract

Bernard Cohn once called the imperial point of view the “view from the boat”. There were other boats as well.In 1893, the sovereign state of Johor adopted the OttomanMedjelle (Meḏj̱elle-yi Aḥkām-i˚ḥʿAdliyye, the civil code applied in the Ottoman Empire since 1877), being the only state among the Muslim sultanates of the Malay Peninsula to do so. In 1895, Johor promulgated a Constitution(Undang-Undang Tubuh Kerajaan Johor), being the first state in Southeast Asia to do so. This article takes this moment, of the intersection of two types of law from quite disparate sources, as a point of departure for tracing the pathways by which law made its way from one corner of the globe to another. Taking nineteenth century Johor as our vantage point provides a new optic for mapping law's geography and temporality and for exploring the logics of law's itinerancy and its locality. The travels of law were always material, and often embodied; on ships sailing the Indian Ocean between Johor and Cairo were diplomats, merchants, pilgrims, and lawyers faced with new pressures and new possibilities; in the growing traffic in letters and newspaper reports between London and New York, Tokyo and Constantinople, were debates about empire and culture, power and authenticity; in personal relationships made possible by the technologies of nineteenth century cosmopolitanism, were similarly worldly dramas of deception and demands for justice. In the 2 short years between the adoption of theMedjelleand the Constitution in Johor, the sultan of Johor, Abu Bakar (1833–1895), typified this mobility and interconnection. In his travels across the Indian Ocean to the Near East and Europe; in his appearance in diplomatic communiques in London, Constantinople and Washington D.C.; in his prominence as a figure of exoticism and intrigue in the newspapers and the courts of the English-speaking world, the sultan not only embodied law's movements in a figurative way, he was also himself a key carrier of the law, and one of its signal articulators.

International organizations and research methods: an introduction

“…Peevers takes this approach in her study of international interventions and says it allows the scholar to see what law makes possible in addition to the standard question of what it forbids (2014). Recognizing that the legal system as productive and empowering for some in addition to being regulative and constraining (Hussin 2014) is the key to opening a broad and grounded empirical research program on the implications of how law and politics are constituted and defined, sometimes as one and sometimes in distinction to each other.…”

The Traveling Waqf: Property, Religion, and Mobility beyond China

“…The waqfiyya in question is one of the few extant pre-Communist waqfiyyas written by and for Hui. Whereas the triconsonantal root of waqf literally means "to bring to a standstill" (Cowan 1976(Cowan : 1278(Cowan -1279, the Ma Lin waqfiyya shows that documents that enshrine rights and obligations in property move, circulate across jurisdictions, both legal and chronological, and attain new meanings as they travel (on such movement, see generally, Hussin 2014). Recent studies of Uyghur documents such as pre-Communist deeds of sale (Sugawara 2010) have cast new light on the linkages between Islam and property prior to the establishment of the modern Chinese state.…”