The results of experimental measurements and theoretical simulations of circular dichroism in the angular dependence (CDAD) of photoemission from atomic core levels of each of the enantiomers of a chiral molecule, alanine, adsorbed on Cu(110) are presented. Measurements in, and out of, substrate mirror planes distinguish CDAD due to the chirality of the sample and the experimental geometry. The effect due to sample chirality is relatively weak, so such measurements may not provide a routine spectral fingerprint of adsorbate chirality. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.92.236103 PACS numbers: 68.43.Fg, 33.55.Ad, 79.60.Dp There has been growing interest in the last few years in the properties of chiral molecules adsorbed on surfaces (e.g., [1][2][3][4][5][6]), motivated in part by the potential importance of producing molecular products of a single ''handedness'' (enantioselective) by heterogeneous catalysis. In such studies a simple spectroscopic measurement, which could establish if the surface species (which may be unknown reaction intermediates) are predominantly of a single chirality, would be of great value. Conventional optical absorption measurements on submonolayer coverages of adsorbed molecules which exploit the circular dichroism (a difference in absorption for left-and rightcircularly polarized radiation) are unlikely to be fruitful. However, spatially oriented chiral molecules, such as those adsorbed on a surface, should show circular dichroism in the angular distribution (CDAD) of photoelectrons emitted from these species [7,8]. Indeed, such an effect has recently been observed [9] even for randomly oriented chiral molecules in the gas phase. Here we present the results of experiments, and model calculations, which evaluate this idea using core level photoemission from one model system, alanine on Cu(110); our results confirm the existence of the effect but show it is weak relative to other sources of CDAD unrelated to the surface chirality, casting doubt on the likely utility of this phenomenon to provide a routine spectral fingerprint.We chose core level photoemission for these CDAD studies because the elemental and chemical-state specificity offered by photoelectron binding energies allows one to localize the information on chirality to specific adsorbed species on a surface; this is not true for photoemission from the valence states in which contributions from substrate and coexistent adsorbed species generally overlap. An important aspect of CDAD, however, is that even nonchiral surfaces give rise to a significant signal if the geometry of the experiment is chiral [10]. If the plane defined by the incident (circularly polarized) light and the photoelectron collection direction does not correspond to a mirror symmetry plane of the sample, the experiments conducted with opposite circular polarizations will not be equivalent and so a circular dichroism signal will be observed. This CDAD effect (up to 50% or more) from core levels of atoms in nonchiral surfaces is well established from substrate atoms [...