Cinema Censorship and Media Citizenship in the Hong Kong Film Ten Years

Abstract

Cinema censorship is a relatively unexplored topic in the discipline of surveillance studies. While movies are frequent references throughout the scholarship, such citations tend to be limited to plot and imagery and overlook the ways in which the medium can be subject to state intervention or other forms of censorship and self-censorship. This essay uses the case of the 2015 Hong Kong independent film Ten Years to explore how cinema deserves to be considered alongside other media and communications whose vulnerability to institutional control and monitoring are already widely documented by surveillance studies. The film, which reflects Hong Kong residents’ critique of mounting Chinese power, was the object of an aggressive vilification and repression campaign by the mainland Chinese government. It also spawned a grassroots defense in which audiences and filmmakers mobilized around the film as a symbol and site of civic discourse and political critique. Using the concepts of participatory media and online activism and connecting Ten Years with Hong Kong’s 2014 “Umbrella” protests against Chinese rule, this essay shows how cinema invites the same interventions and interactivity as social media and other digital or communications technologies. Indeed, because Ten Years’ history of populist activism resembles well-known instances of media mobilization such as the Arab Spring and Black Lives Matter, this essay demonstrates not only cinema’s multiple dimensions of relevance for surveillance studies but also uncovers new global spaces whose film history will diversify surveillance studies.

Relationship of living historical memories and news source with national identity: A latent class analysis

“…Our finding is consistent with a previous study conducted in China, which found that the more one was exposed to news (e.g., through newspaper, television, or radio), the more one developed trust in government (Shen & Guo, 2013). Therefore, it makes sense that the same pattern was uncovered in Hong Kong, where traditional news sources are increasingly censored by the government, or self-censored (Chan & Lee, 2007;Fang, 2018;Weber & Fan, 2016). However, we also found that digital media use in Hong Kong was associated with more negative attitudes toward the government, the system, and the nation, which may reflect a widening split between the central government and the Hong Kong society.…”

“…In the context of Hong Kong, after the Handover, the political relationship between Hong Kong and Beijing has become one of the largest influences on Hong Kong media (F. L. F. Chan & Lee, 2007). Hong Kong's traditional mass media (i.e., television news, newspaper, and radio) is suggested to be increasingly deferential to the political interests of Beijing and its corporate allies in Hong Kong (Frisch, Belair-Gagnon, & Agur, 2018) and were reportedly being censored by authorities (Fang, 2018;Kan, 2019;Weber & Fan, 2016). Such exposure to censored media predicts higher national identification and political trust (Shen & Guo, 2013).…”

Tracing Evolution and Communication Dynamics in Chinese Independent Documentary Films (2012-2022): A Systematic Review of Genre, Censorship, Culture, and Distribution

“…However, they also face challenges posed by the censorship regime, especially since 2012, when the tightening of film censorship has made the dissemination of independent films more difficult. Thus, the topic of film censorship remains an underexplored area in independent film studies (Fang, 2018). Despite these challenges, independent documentaries have made significant contributions to civic culture, reflecting an aesthetic of observation that stimulates reflection and discussion (Troost, 2022).…”

Citizenship and Education in Hong Kong: A Review of Contemporary Academic Literature

“…Fang (2018) argues that some of the most prominent media to emerge in recent years have sought to not only highlight the growing tensions and anxieties within Hong Kong society at the growing encroachment of the Mainland, but also to draw parallels which are pertinent to those outside of Hong Kong. Increases in political participation among the local population, particularly as antagonism towards the Central government, led to a rise in a “localist” political sphere (Xia, 2016).…”

“…Given that the protests in 2019 were largely seen as student-led movements, it follows that this will also have had a significant impact on how young people in Hong Kong conceptualise their sense of citizenship and identity related to the territory, although this remains to be seen. Fang (2018) argues that some of the most prominent media to emerge in recent years have sought to not only highlight the growing tensions and anxieties within Hong Kong society at the growing encroachment of the Mainland, but also to draw parallels which are pertinent to those outside of Hong Kong. Increases in political participation among the local population, particularly as antagonism towards the Central government, led to a rise in a "localist" political sphere (Xia, 2016).…”