“…Clark et al (2012), Svendsen et al (2015) and Hughes et al (2016), however, consider the possibility of a long period of sustained confluence between the two ice sheets, but with reduced extent over the North Sea area following a preceding phase of maximum western expansion. Regardless of these uncertainties, the general picture of the southwestern flank of the ice sheet is that of a highly oscillatory ice margin with multiple advances and retreats following early attainment of maximum icesheet limits (e.g., Nygård et al, 2004Nygård et al, , 2007Hubbard et al, 2009;Sejrup et al, 2009;Mangerud et al, 2013;Vorren et al, 2015;Hughes et al, 2016). At the same time, there was steady eastward growth of the ice sheet (Hughes et al, 2016), finally culminating in long, low-gradient ice lobes in NW Russia .…”