PurposeOur study examined the association between outpatient postsurgical analgesic prescription and risk of insufficiently managed pain characterized by pain‐associated hospital admission and emergency room (ER) visit.MethodsEligible individuals were children 1–17 years of age who filled an incident analgesic following an outpatient surgery during 2013–2018. Pain‐associated hospital admission or ER visit were measured within 30 days following the outpatient surgical procedure. A hierarchical multivariable logistic regression model with patients nested under prescribers was fitted to test the association between incident analgesic prescription and risk of having pain‐associated hospital admission or ER visit.ResultsOf 14 277 children meeting the inclusion criteria, 6224 (43.6%) received an incident opioid and 8053 (56.4%) received an incident non‐opioid analgesic prescription respectively. There were a total of 523 (3.7%) children undergoing surgical procedures that had pain‐related hospital admissions or ER visits with 5.1% initiated on non‐opioid analgesics and 1.8% on opioid analgesics. The multilevel model indicated that initial opioid analgesic recipients were 32% less likely of having a pain‐associated hospital admission or ER visit [aOR: 0.68 (95% CI: 0.3–0.8)].ConclusionMajority of postsurgical patients do not require additional pain management strategies. In the 3.7% of patients requiring additional pain management strategies, those initiated on non‐opioid analgesics are more likely to have a pain‐associated hospital admission or ER visit compared with their opioid recipient counterparts.