Chronic groin pain following open inguinal hernia repair: has consenting practice improved?

Abstract

Introduction Chronic groin pain following inguinal hernia surgery is a common and potentially debilitating complication, and yet patients are infrequently informed of this risk. This leaves surgeons open to negligence claims, especially given recent changes to case law, which for the first time highlighted the need for a more patient-centred approach to risk disclosure. We investigated how these changes have influenced our consenting practice with respect to the disclosure of this risk. Methods We compared how often surgeons discussed the risk of chronic groin pain with adults undergoing elective open unilateral inguinal hernia mesh repairs in 2019 and 2009. The first 50 patients in each of these two years were retrospectively compared. Discussions during the initial consultation and on the day of surgery were assessed by reviewing clinic letters, medical notes and consent forms. Findings The risk of chronic pain was discussed with significantly more patients in 2019 than in 2009 (96% v 54%, p<0.0001). Most of these discussions occurred on the day of surgery (92% v 54%, p<0.0001). Only a few patients had these discussions during their initial consultation (18% v 4%, p<0.025). Conclusions Discussing the risk of chronic groin pain has improved significantly over the past 10 years. However, these discussions occur mostly on the day of surgery, which gives patients very little time to weigh up the risk. This potentially invalidates the consent they give for surgery. Patients should be given an opportunity to discuss their operative risks in advance of their operation.

Fıtık Cerrahisi

“…Ancak cerrahlar tarafından bu bilgilendirmenin çoğunlukla hastanın ilk poliklinik başvurusu yerine operasyon gününde yapıldığı görülüyor. Bu durumda hastalar operasyonun risklerini detaylı düşünmek için yeterli zamana sahip olmuyor bu da hastanın operasyon için verdiği onayı potansiyel olarak geçersiz kılıyor (89). Bu nedenle hastalara inguinal herni onarımının beklenen komplikasyonlarından biri olan kronik kasık ağrısı gelişim riski operasyon kararı verilmeden önce detaylıca anlatılması tarafımızca önerilmektedir.…”