China and Africa: Model of South-South Cooperation?

Abstract

Chinese officials often claim that their country’s massive involvement in Africa is an example of “South-South cooperation” with tremendous potential to unlock Africa’s development prospects. They maintain that China’s economic involvement in the continent is less exploitative and more relevant to local needs than the North’s. Starting from a relatively small amount of investment in the early 1990s, China has become Africa’s biggest economic partner. Yet, as the United Nations Conference on Trade and Investment (UNCTAD) and other studies have shown, Chinese trade and investment in Africa are reproducing African countries as exporters of raw materials and importers of manufactured goods. This paper deconstructs the uncritical view of China’s development cooperation with Africa as “South-South” cooperation, highlighting its potential tensions, incongruities, downsides, and dilemmas. It demonstrates both good and bad news. Recent data show that despite the slowdown of the Chinese economy and slump in prices of certain raw materials, the total value of China-Africa trade is on the rise, with Africa’s exports to China growing rapidly, indicating a narrowing gap between imports and exports in the bilateral trade. However, whether this phenomenon is sustainable remains in doubt. Dynamics of the boom and bust cycles of commodity markets, limited diversification, domestic institutional constraints, limited tariff exemptions and rising debt on African countries can all compromise the recent progress in China-Africa trade and exacerbate their asymmetrical relationship, reproducing the trade pattern between the West and African countries.

Resource-Financed Infrastructure: Thoughts on Four Chinese-Financed Projects in Uganda

“…Another criticism that is sometimes made is that many projects funded by these arrangements are vanity projects that are not consistent with the country's real development needs [39]. There is also a concern relating to the perpetuation of African countries as sellers of unprocessed raw materials, which keeps them in a state of dependency and perpetuates neo-imperialism and neo-colonialism [68].…”

Kenya's regional ambitions or China's Belt‐and‐Road? News media representations of the Mombasa‐Nairobi Standard Gauge Railway

“…South‐South cooperation has been invoked in debates over whether China's role in Africa differs from colonial forms of control, and neo‐colonial agendas of Western aid and development assistance (Flint & Waddoups, 2019; Asante, 2018). China has a long history of investment in Africa, beginning with support for newly independent African countries in the 1960s which reflected both China's socialist ideology and the embrace of this ideology by a number of African anti‐colonial movements (Strange, 2019).…”

China-Cameroon: A win-lose relationship in the Mining sector?

“…Other authors, who see the results of the Chinese economic engagement on the continent as quite mixed, think that one can hardly be categorical about Chinese engagement. To Asante (2018), "while there are positive signs that the trade gap between both sides is narrowing, there are questions about its sustainability." The author notes that the pattern of Chinese imports reveals a strong domination of natural resources while Africa on its side mainly imports manufactured goods.…”