Chemical understanding and graphing skills in an honors case‐based computerized chemistry laboratory environment: The value of bidirectional visual and textual representations

Abstract

The case-based computerized laboratory (CCL) is a chemistry learning environment that integrates computerized experiments with emphasis on scientific inquiry and comprehension of case studies. The research objective was to investigate chemical understanding and graphing skills of high school honors students via bidirectional visual and textual representations in the CCL learning environment. The research population of our 3-year study consisted of 857 chemistry 12th grade honors students from a variety of high schools in Israel. Pre-and postcase-based questionnaires were used to assess students' graphing and chemical understanding-retention skills. We found that students in the CCL learning environment significantly improved their graphing skills and chemical understanding-retention in the post-with respect to the prequestionnaires. Comparing the experimental students to their non-CCL control peers has shown that CCL students had an advantage in graphing skills. The CCL contribution was most noticeable for experimental students of relatively low academic level who benefit the most from the combination of visual and textual representations. Our findings emphasize the educational value of combining the case-based method with computerized laboratories for enhancing students' chemistry understanding and graphing skills, and for developing their ability to bidirectionally transfer between textual and visual representations. ß A growing body of research is concerned with the contribution of external representations to high-level cognitive processing of information

How Much Have They Retained? Making Unseen Concepts Seen in a Freshman Electromagnetism Course at MIT

“…Since the gain of the experimental group was double that of the control group, the potential for ''forgetting'' was higher, but, nonetheless, the retention of the experimental students remained significantly higher than their peers. This is in accordance with another study of high school honors studentsÕ retention that investigated a computerized chemistry laboratory environment which emphasized visualizations, teamwork, hands-on activities, and embedded assessment (Dori and Sasson, 2008). The present research also indicated that some TEAL students were able to transfer the knowledge and skills from the TEAL E&M course to advanced courses.…”

Computer-Based Scaffolding Strategy

“…Other strategies used as the basis of the customization of computer-based scaffolding included setting scaffolding to reduce in strength according to fixed time intervals (fixed fading) (Dori & Sasson, 2008;McNeill, Lizotte, Krajcik, & Marx, 2006;Philpot, Hall, Hubing, & Flori, 2005) or when students click a button (selfselected fading) (Clark, Touchman, Martinez-Garza, Ramirez-Marin, & Skjerping Drews, 2012;Metcalf, 1999;Renkl, 2002). Customization based on fixed time intervals means that the scaffold designer determines time intervals after which scaffolding should be faded or added.…”

Pre-service Science Teachers' Views on Laboratory Applications in Science Education: The Effect of a Two-semester Course

“…In the light of all these, it can be said that even though the importance of laboratory applications in science education has long been acknowledged, recent years witnessed a surging interest in laboratory works and practical work. Literature has revealed that laboratory practices are useful in terms of students' both cognitive and affective development [6]. In terms of cognitive skills, laboratories are places where students learn the concepts, principles, and laws by exploring with experiments [7].…”