In
this work, static adsorption/precipitation (Γ/Π)
experiments were conducted for two widely used scale inhibitors (DETPMP
and VS-Co) using two different size fractions of Moroccan calcite
(315–500 and 125–250 μm) to study the effect of
particle size on the “apparent adsorption” of these
SIs onto carbonate. The reason for performing these experiments at
two particle size ranges was to determine whether the relative surface
area to volume ratios (as presented as particle size) would affect
whether the precipitating SI–Ca complex forms as a “skin”
on the mineral surface and, if so, to determine whether this “skin”
could affect the further interaction between the SI and the carbonate
mineral by a “surface poisoning” effect. The results
of both environmental scanning electron microscopy/energy dispersive
X-ray analysis (ESEM/EDX) and direct particle size analysis (PSA)
clearly showed that no (or very little), such surface deposition or
coating around calcite grains occurred for either of these SIs. Essentially,
the results for both particle sizes were qualitatively the same for
each of the SIs. The DETPMP retention showed coupled Γ/Π
behavior, which was predominantly precipitation at [DETPMP] > 100
ppm and was quantitatively almost the same for both calcite particle
sizes. Likewise, the results for VS-Co were quantitatively almost
identical for both particle sizes and the retention was predominantly
via adsorption up to [VS-Co] ≈ 3000 ppm, with some small degree
of precipitation at higher concentration observed. The rather different
behavior of DETPMP and VS-Co may be ascribed to different functional
groups having different pK
a values and
strengths of SI–Ca binding. Both sets of static adsorption/precipitation
experimental results for DETPMP and VS-Co on each calcite particle
size fraction were also predicted using a previously published model.