Pseudemys alabamensis
is one of the most endangered freshwater turtle species in the United States due to its restricted geographic distribution in coastal Alabama and Mississippi. Populations of
P. alabamensis
are geographically isolated from one another by land and saltwater, which could act as barriers to gene flow. It is currently unknown how differentiated these populations are from one another and whether they have experienced reductions in population size. Previous work found morphological differences between Alabama and Mississippi populations, suggesting that they may be evolutionarily distinct. Other
Pseudemys
turtles such as
P. concinna
and
P. floridana
occur naturally within the same geographic area as
P. alabamensis
and are known to hybridize with each other. These more abundant species could threaten the unique genetic identity of
P. alabamensis
through introgression. In order to evaluate the endangered status of
P. alabamensis
and the level of hybridization with other species, we used mitochondrial and nuclear microsatellite markers to assess genetic variation within and among populations of
P. alabamensis
throughout its range and estimate admixture with co‐occurring
Pseudemys
species. In
P. alabamensis
, we found no variation in mitochondrial DNA and an excess of homozygosity in microsatellite data. Our results show genetic differentiation between Alabama and Mississippi populations of
P. alabamensis
, and low estimated breeding sizes and signs of inbreeding for two populations (Fowl River, Alabama and Biloxi, Mississippi). We also found evidence of admixture between
P. alabamensis
and
P. concinna
/
P. floridana
. Based on our results,
P. alabamensis
is highly endangered throughout its range and threatened by both low population sizes and hybridization. In order to improve the species’ chances of survival, focus should be placed on habitat preservation, maintenance of genetic diversity within both the Mississippi and Alabama populations, and routine population‐monitoring activities such as nest surveillance and estimates of recruitment.